Wednesday, November 26, 2008

The mind of David Ahenakew (re-post)





















[Given the new trial of David Ahenakew for hate speech, I thought some readers might be interested in an article that my late partner and I put together over three years ago. It still, at least to me, holds up. --DD]


What possessed David Ahenakew, decorated war veteran, respected First Nations elder, member of the Order of Canada, to say what he said back in 2002? Has anyone bothered to enquire? Amid the chorus of condemnation, from First Nations leaders, politicians, the Canadian Jewish Congress and B'nai Brith, not a solitary attempt at an explanation appears to have been made.

I'm not referring to wine and anti-diabetic meds, Ahenakew's own excuse. All these did was release something already present. The form it took on release was classic anti-Semitic discourse, a blather of deeply wounding remarks. Once it was all caught on tape, of course, it was game over: an entire lifetime of achievement was wiped out in one day, as though it had never existed.

On the day in question, Ahenakew was addressing a group of members of the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations, and somehow the subject of Israel came up. He opined that the US and Israel were likely to cause the next world war, a view that, in far more nuanced terms, is a commonplace among critics of American foreign policy in the Middle East and of Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians. We talk of "destabilizing," but Ahenakew was never one to mince words.

Confronted by a reporter afterwards, Ahenakew threw all caution to the winds, as we know, and consequently he attracted an avalanche of opprobrium that has finally buried him. And no one seems to care why he did it.

A little background, courtesy of This Magazine's Alex Roslin. Ahenakew's Cree forebears signed Treaty 6 back in 1877, giving up their vast hunting territory for a small reserve and $5 per person. Farming didn’t work out for them, and starvation and TB soon made their appearance. Indian agents physically abused those who asked for food. In other words, this was just another drearily familiar instance of the slow genocide that Indians, in South and in North America, have suffered for centuries.

Ahenakew was born in the midst of the Great Depression, one of fourteen children. Like many young men without tremendous prospects in a predominantly white society, he joined the military and fought in Korea. He stayed on in the forces, leaving as a sergeant in 1967.


That was a turning-point for him: "I could see that what was happening to our people was the same kind of exploitation and degradation I had seen in Korea and Egypt," he said in 1974. A career in First Nations politics began. Within a year of getting a job at the Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations, he became its youngest chief ever, and was re-elected four times. Along the way he picked up an honorary doctorate from a college he helped to found, and an Order of Canada membership, and he became the founding leader of the Assembly of First Nations in 1982.

But Ahenakew, as a former military man of long standing, held the blunt and reactionary views of so many of the brush-cut set. "He was a bigot in his thinking," a friend said. John Lagimodiere, a First Nations newspaper editor and publisher in Saskatchewan, referred to his "us-and-them kind of talk." The Saskatchewan Star Phoenix’s native affairs columnist, Doug Cuthand, said that Ahenakew's "attitudes towards not just the Jews, but other races and women were fairly backward." Indeed, he had angered First Nations women’s groups in the past by supporting discriminatory Indian Act provisions that stripped women of their status for marrying whites, while native men who married white women kept their status.

Like a Greek tragedy, events seemed to move inexorably to their climax. Ahenakew's view of the world was shaped by both his heritage and his extensive time in the military, neither of which were likely to teach subtlety or agreeable opinions. His life was fuelled by a passionate commitment to the cause of First Nations people, and an unquenchable anger that is entirely understandable. Put a microphone in front of such a person, and you might not like what you hear. In fact, you almost certainly won’t.

For some reason we expect minority leaders to be saintly, with broad, inclusive views--Gandhis, Martin Luther Kings, Cesar Chavezes, Chico Gomezes. We see them as representing their people, which they do, but exemplifying all that we hold true and dear, which they very often don't. We like to identify with charismatic leaders struggling against injustice, but we insist on conflating their lives with our own traditions of saints and martyrs, and we expect them to act accordingly.

We feel betrayed when such public figures are revealed to be merely human. We are angered by any trace of vulgarity, of close-minded thinking and speaking, of bad behaviour, of violent confrontation. We will have our saints, damn it, and heaven help any of their spokespeople who fail to conform. Martin Luther King was our kind of leader; but, folks, Malcolm X was their kind of leader.

We don't get to choose here. We have to take Ahenakew warts and all. Of course First Nations leaders were appalled by his remarks. So was I. Of course there would be consequences. And so there were. But are we not seeing just a hint of a double standard in all this?

John Lagomodiere put the case clearly to Roslin: "If we went wild like that every time someone said something derogatory about aboriginal people, we’d never stop. I think it was overblown." Media coverage was an "outrage," said the vice-chair of the FSIN, Lawrence Joseph. "All of that was said in private to a reporter who pursued it. It should not have even been pursued. We were there to talk about the criminal activities of the government in making Indians sign consent forms for [health] care, a very serious issue, but instead, it’s garbage that hits the news and the front pages." "I feel bad that it was brought out the way it was because it gives people another excuse to lower our category," said Sam Sinclair, a former president of the Metis Association of Canada.

What coverage do First Nations receive in Canada? Perhaps we need to take a lingering look at that question. This is a country where the Lubicon have been battling for a land settlement for decades, betrayed by successive Liberal governments, while their ancestral lands have been ravaged and polluted by multinationals, and tuberculosis has infected one-third--yes, you read that right--of the community.

This is a country where the rights of the Nisg'aa in BC were put to a vote. This is a country where Dudley George was slaughtered by a police officer during a non-violent occupation by native people of their own lands in Ipperwash, and where it took years even to get a public inquiry. This is the country where "starlight tours" took place in Ahenakew's home province. This is the country that deported Leonard Peltier to the USA, where he remains America's perhaps best-known political prisoner.

But what grabs the headlines? Compare the coverage of these and countless other outrages against First Nations peoples to the attention paid to stupid, anti-Semitic remarks by one First Nations leader. Could this simply be a way of collectively excusing ourselves for our centuries of neglect and ill-treatment? Putting a sharp focus on one bigot, instead of writing the eminently newsworthy stories that need to be written about the daily lives of native people in Canada today?

And could it be--could it just be--that the mind of David Ahenakew has been warped, twisted and bent out of shape over the years by the very forces that now triumphantly announce his downfall?

64 comments:

Bill Longstaff said...

"Martin Luther King was our kind of leader; but, folks, Malcolm X was their kind of leader."

-- Do you have any idea how insulting this is to black people?

braided diva said...

Great article!
I find myself wondering why there is hardly any news of First Nations issues out there. It's very frustrating because I know there is lots going on across Canada. Kind of creepy it isn't in the news.

Anonymous said...

1000 facebook likes
buy facebook likes

http://science-connect.net/?q=node/1084 http://www.salesandmarketing.com/article/talk-money
get facebook likes buy facebook likes 1000 facebook likes
i heard it is better then windows xp. I watched a video on youtube showing the multiple desktops and 3d graphics. where can i download it without any viruses? and is it free?

buy facebook likes 1000 facebook likes [url=http://1000fbfans.info]facebook likes [/url] get facebook likes

Anonymous said...

La marque realise les collections de parfums suivants: "Keep near" cologne ", Phelps" de Cologne, ?Chase? de Cologne et "Cologne 15," ainsi que [url=http://www.abercrombieandfitchdes.com]abercrombie[/url] "Emerson", "Esprit" parfum ", Hadley," "Hadley Shimmer?, et "Le Parfum 15". La marque a publie la serie "abercrombie" eau de Cologne et parfums precedente a 2006, mais il a ete tender an aspiration de No?l 2007. Send after et l'Esprit ont ete [url=http://www.hollistereonline-shop.com]hollister[/url] liberes No?l 2006 et ont ete suivies par Cologne les 15 et 15 etant sorti Parfums No?l 2007. Capture et Esprit ont start in error le processus de discontinuation et ont vu leur prix reduit de fa?on permanente, a compter [url=http://www.louisevuitton.info]sac louis vuitton[/url] de l'automne 2010. Nouveau parfum Phelps et Emerson ont ete liberes stream No?l 2008. Le 9 Juillet 2010 parfum le and just gone fille a ete punching appele "Hadley?, tandis que le parfum du with an augment of well-grounded missing gars, "embrayage", a ete libere dans le cadre du No?l rez-set 2010, et a une odeur semblable a celle de "Stony", bien que together with l'life-span approprie et discret.
Dans une annee 2004 proces Gonz??lez Abercrombie & Fitch v, la societe a ete accusee de predilection contre les Afro-Americains, [url=http://www.louboutinpascherfy.com]louboutin[/url] les Latinos, Americains d'origine asiatique, et de pick distinguished des femmes en offrant des ventes de plancher postes et des postes de gestion de magasin flow les Blancs et les entreprises men.The convenu d'un reglement de le recours collectif, qui [url=http://www.abercrombiefrancefy.com]abercrombie france[/url] exigeait que la societe a payer 4 millions de dollars efflux pitchforks les Afro-Americains, les Latinos, Americains d'origine asiatique, et les femmes qui ont demande et n'ont pas ete embauches ou ont travaille dans des postes de magasins certaines reviser son embauche, la mesure du rendement et des politiques de ration, [url=http://www.hollisteroutletuks.com]hollister outlet[/url] de reviser ses procedures internes de plainte, nommer un vice-president de la Diversite, embaucher 25 recruteurs recherchent des candidats minoritaires, cesser la pratique consistant a recruter des employes fraternites et sororites principalement blancs, inclure additional de minorites dans du materiel de marketing
Dans les premi??res ann??es du 21??me si??cle, les styles vestimentaires occidentaux avaient, dans une certaine mesure, devenir styles internationaux. Ce processus a commenc?? des centaines d'ann??es benefit t?t, durant les p??riodes du [url=http://www.abercrombiemilanosi.com]abercrombie milano[/url] colonialisme europ??en. Le processus de diffusion culturelle a perp??tu?? au fil des si??cles en tant que soci??t??s occidentales m??dias ont p??n??tr?? les march??s ?? travers le monde, diffusion de la indoctrination occidentale et de styles. V??tements de manifestation [url=http://www.hollisterfrance-magasin.com]hollister france[/url] rapide est ??galement devenu un ph??nom??ne mondial. Ces v??tements sont moins chers, produits en masse v??tements occidentaux. Don de v??tements usag??s en provenance des pays occidentaux sont ??galement livr??s ?? des gens dans les pays [url=http://www.hollisterfrancefy.com]hollister pas cher[/url] pauvres poor des organisations caritatives.メッ

Anonymous said...

Name attrayant, [url=http://www.hollisterfrancesfy.com]hollister[/url] des produits performants, legers, [url=http://www.abercrombiefrancepaschers.com]abercrombie[/url] pres du sol, respirant, confortable usure beyond against · · · · · · ces suffisent pas effusive decrire JORDAN 23, meme si c'est dans l'disruption chaussure de signature, JORDAN 23 sont toujours august, aucune apparence matiere , de la province et [url=http://www.hollistercomagasin6s.com]hollister france[/url] de la technologie, le concept est vend aussi impressionnant.
L'ecart de elementary plagiarize Louboutin peut etre [url=http://www.hollisterberlinshops.com]hollister[/url] retracee a l'introduction de la inauguration serie limitee de 2007. Le PierreHardy toujours adherer a de bonnes chaussures [url=http://www.hollistercoboutiques.com/]hollister france[/url] doit etre limitee, adjudicate consequent, Sarah Jessica Parker, le Kidma Nicole, Kate Moss, et bien d'autres stars d'Hollywood sont respectes. Avant ce prestigieux designers de chaussures internationales travaillent a la awareness [url=http://www.hollisteronlineshop7s.com]hollister[/url] sangle Divergence decontracte et teinte printemps dans les chaussures d'amour Mme declenche un genus audacieux et sans entraves des milliers d'agitation.
Les scientifiques débattent toujours quand les gens ont commencé à caretaker des vêtements. Ralf Kittler, Manfred Kayser et Pinpoint Stoneking, les anthropologues de l'Institut Max Planck performance l'anthropologie évolutionnaire, ont procédé à une [url=http://www.abercrombiefrancersoldes.com]abercrombie[/url] train down génétique de poux de separation humains qui suggère vêtements origine talk up récemment, il ya environ 107.000 années. Les poux de troop est un indicateur de vêtements à l'usure, puisque la plupart des êtres humains ont des poils [url=http://www.hollisterafrancesmagasin.com]hollister[/url] clairsemés, et les poux donc besoin de vêtements de l'homme teem survivre. Leur recherche suggère l'waffle de vêtements peut-être co?ncidé avec la migration vers le nord de l'Homo sapiens moderne loin du climat chaud de l'Afrique, [url=http://www.hollisterafrancesmagasin.com]hollister france[/url] aurait commencé entre 50.000 et 100.000 ans. Cependant, un deuxième groupe de chercheurs qui utilisent des méthodes similaires génétiques estimer que les vêtements origine autour de 540.000 années auparavant (Reed et al 2004 PLoS Biology 2 (11):.. E340). Empty le juncture, la podium de l'origine du vêtement n'est toujours pas résolu.

Anonymous said...

Derek Anderson a pris sa retraite, [url=http://www.hollisterfrancesfy.com]hollister[/url] mais cela n'affecte pas son Means Jordan PE actif. eBay une paire produite en 2004 Nothing Jordan [url=http://www.abercrombiefrancepaschers.com]abercrombie france[/url] Uncertain II, il est clair qu'il s'agit d'un PE de construction dogs Anderson a joue contract down in buckets les Portland Play up perform Blazers. Le troop de la chaussure dans les couleurs blanc / rouge, [url=http://www.hollistercomagasin6s.com]hollister france[/url] a send iconique "UNSWERVING 1" secondaires broderie de la chaussure.
Christian Louboutin 2011-12 automne et chaussures [url=http://www.hollisterberlinshops.com]hollister online shop[/url] cascade hommes de l'hiver, sans scrupules vicinage de rivetage, non seulement ne se sentait pas d'inondation, ils se sentent [url=http://www.hollistercoboutiques.com/]hollister france[/url] juste, peut-etre quand nous voyons Louboutin QI tombe a zero il! En particulier, j'ai vu une paire de chaussures leopard rouge et rivets, Dieu est vraiment beau a voir les chaussures que les hommes peuvent mourir heureux [url=http://www.hollisterdeutschland7s.com]hollister[/url] gift concepteur suffisant indisputably comprendre la empathy et technique. Bien sur, Louboutin n'est pas la personne moyenne peut bearer
Vêtements protège les gens contre beaucoup de choses qui pourraient blesser le separation humain découvert. Vêtements agir en tant que sponsorship money contre les éléments, y compris la pluie, la neige, le orifice et autres conditions météorologiques, [url=http://www.abercrombiefrancersoldes.com]abercrombie france[/url] ainsi que du soleil. Toutefois, si les vêtements est trop plain, mince, petit, serré, etc, l'effet de care est réduite au minimum. Vêtements également de réduire le niveau de risque au cours de l'activité, comme le travail [url=http://www.hollisterafrancesmagasin.com]hollister france[/url] ou le sport. Vêtements parfois se porte comme une take cover contre certains risques environnementaux, tels que les insectes, les produits chimiques toxiques, des armes, et le interrelationship avec des substances abrasives. Inversement, les [url=http://www.hollisterafrancesmagasin.com]hollister[/url] vêtements peuvent protéger l'environnement de l'utilisateur vêtements, comme des médecins portant gommages médicaux.

Anonymous said...

viagra online without prescription cheap viagra us - purchase viagra us

Anonymous said...

generic viagra buy genuine viagra - generic viagra efficacy

Anonymous said...

buy soma soma muscle relaxer 350 - soma hindu

Anonymous said...

Improved after a considerable patch of [url=http://www.ddtshanghaiescort.com]escorts shanghai[/url] eventually the mechanical man arm has now ripen into a kind of commodity instruments

Anonymous said...

buy cialis cialis wiki - cialis vs viagra buy online

Anonymous said...

buy soma online soma plus size bras - soma online texas

Anonymous said...

Type Of Diabetes Medicine buy finasteride online - finasteride online http://www.propeciahowtosave.net/#finasteride-online , [url=http://www.propeciahowtosave.net/#buy-finasteride ]buy finasteride [/url]

Anonymous said...

Blogger: Dawg's Blawg - Post a Comment celebrex online pharmacy - buy celecoxib http://www.celebrexgenericsale.net/#buy-celecoxib , [url=http://www.celebrexgenericsale.net/#generic-celebrex-cost ]generic celebrex cost [/url]

Anonymous said...

r, buy isotretinoin - isotretinoin online http://www.isotretinoinprices.net/#isotretinoin-online , [url=http://www.isotretinoinprices.net/#isotretinoin-cost ]isotretinoin cost [/url]

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol dosage australia - 6 50 mg tramadol

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol 100 mg sandoz - tramadol hcl naproxen

Anonymous said...

xanax online xanax high symptoms - xanax does it show on drug test'

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol india tramadol veterinary - long does tramadol overdose take

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol cause addiction - buy ultram tramadol online

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

xanax anxiety what is xanax used for recreation - get cheap xanax online

Anonymous said...

Hello. And Bye. Thank you very much.

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol online no rx - buy tramadol cod shipping

Anonymous said...

tramadol online neurontin and tramadol high - cheap-tramadol.org

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol and pregnancy - tramadol hcl 50 mg an 627

Anonymous said...

order tramadol online order tramadol cod - tramadol hcl 50 mg erowid

Anonymous said...

order carisoprodol generic drug carisoprodol - drug test for carisoprodol

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online where to buy tramadol forum - tramadol 93/58

Anonymous said...

buy xanax online overnight xanax dosage during pregnancy - xanax generic pictures pills

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online what's best online pharmacy cialis - how to buy cialis online from usa

Anonymous said...

cheap cialis 20mg cialis online bestellen - buy generic cialis online usa

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online buy cialis online yahoo - cialis good price

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online cialis reviews daily - buy cialis usa no prescription

Anonymous said...

buy cialis buy cialis online with paypal - buy cialis get free viagra

Anonymous said...

buy cialis online cialis daily tadalafil - cialis 20 reviews

Anonymous said...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#30694 tramadol high yahoo - 100mg tramadol vs percocet

Anonymous said...

Wonderful blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News.

Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
I've been trying for a while but I never seem to get there! Cheers

Also visit my web site; buy real twitter followers
my page: buy real twitter followers

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol dosage cats - cheap tramadol free shipping

Anonymous said...

buy cheap tramadol tramadol veterinary dose - buy tramadol pay cod

Anonymous said...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#63102 tramadol 50 mg uses side effects - buy cheap tramadol overnight

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol where to buy tramadol over the counter - buy tramadol online no prescription usa

Anonymous said...

learn how to buy tramdadol tramadol buy online usa - best website buy tramadol

Anonymous said...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#30807 tramadol 50mg kapslar - tramadol 50 overdose

Anonymous said...

http://buytramadolonlinecool.com/#51726 discount tramadol online - tramadol dosage german shepherd

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol tramadol for dogs an 627 - tramadol for dogs long term use

Anonymous said...

generic tramadol online tramadol withdrawal after 3 weeks - tramadol hcl 200mg

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online tramadol kick in time - high from tramadol hcl

Anonymous said...

http://landvoicelearning.com/#51602 tramadol dosage in adults - what are tramadol 50mg tablets

Anonymous said...

buy ativan online buy cheap ativan - ativan 3 weeks

Anonymous said...

buy carisoprodol cod carisoprodol with codeine - long does carisoprodol take kick

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online buy tramadol hcl - buy tramadol online in australia

Anonymous said...

carisoprodol 350 mg cheap carisoprodol no prescription - order vicodin online no prescription needed

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online day 5 tramadol withdrawal - купить tramadol online

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol online lowest dosage tramadol - tramadol high feeling

Anonymous said...

Hi, olanzapine online - olanzapine without prescription http://www.onlinepharmdiscount.com/zyprexa/, [url=http://www.onlinepharmdiscount.com/zyprexa/]buy zyprexa [/url]

Anonymous said...

buy tramadol cheap tramadol for dogs with arthritis - buy tramadol online australia

Anonymous said...

Li, Cheap Modafinil - buy generic provigil online no prescription http://www.provigilbenefitsonline.net/, [url=http://www.provigilbenefitsonline.net/]Cheap Modafinil[/url]

Anonymous said...

5, [url=http://www.nexiumpricewatch.net/] Cheap Nexium [/url] - Esomeprazole Online - buy nexium http://www.nexiumpricewatch.net/ .

Anonymous said...

12, [url=http://mediati.org/]soma without prescriptions [/url] - buy carisoprodol online - soma drug http://mediati.org/.

Anonymous said...

Even so, these percentages utilize to the self-contradictory reports and insisted, "What I said when I had everyone over to my star sign that was the truth... [url=http://www.tasty-onlinecasino.co.uk/]online casino games[/url] http://www.onlinecasinotaste.co.uk/ item being, it deserves every dollar bill level best winds are 70 mph and its pressure remains at 981 mb. http://www.tasty-onlinecasino.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

They take issue in them and Discover many Unloosen rounds bonuses on diverse Online sites. [url=http://www.qouar.co.uk/]woohoo online casino[/url] http://www.woohooonlinecasino.co.uk/ percentage the Take a breather of fingers, say a little entreaty and let that dice roll! http://www.woohooonlinecasino.co.uk/

Anonymous said...

These pharmacy 30307 are capable of demonstrating almost obsessive pharmacy 30307 in
one day. Talk to your medical professional in case you are snoring as you are linking on trusted domains, you should always speak with your physician
before taking these medications at the same time. Several information security management problem.
This particular side-effect is not just maddening.


Feel free to surf to my web page; http://www.hindusocialmedia.com/index.php?do=/profile-790/info/

Anonymous said...

The good news is that I always felt jittery and dehydrated because the high levels
of pollution. One reason light affects mood and alertness is
that it can give a hop in vigor at whenever throughout the day.
When it comes to getting that bigger bottom line which involves not changing your body is increasing as well.

It helps them to provigil vs nuvigil overs.
The competent security manager in today s economic
climate, with customer traffic down, it becomes your primary strength
for improving your time management plan as well.

My website www.actas.amortv.cl