Thursday, June 11, 2009

Outing, revisited

My last post on this subject was mainly concerned with the outing of American blogger "publius" by National Review's Ed Whelan. But I asked readers to comment on the ethics of outing. I noted that, were I to get into this practice, it would be with those who believe they have outed me. Motive is important. It's a moral thing.

So it happened that I came across a fascinating thread over at Small Dead Ideas today.
Warren Kinsella quoted me yesterday anent the pseudonymous "Raphael Alexander," and so the two of us had the privilege of being nibbled by the angry mice over there.

Among the rodents is an ex-professor from Bishop's University, one Edwina Taborsky, who blogs under the entirely suitable initials "ET." She thought she'd have a go at outing me.*

Now, turnabout, you might think, is fair play.

Not so, it seems. When a couple of rascals immediately did to her what she had just done to me, she filled cyberspace with a shrill, outraged whine. Unethical!*

As long as someone is posting on a blog, and using a pseudonym on that blog - and we know that some people use different pseudonyms on different blogs - then, ethics requires that you, on that blog, acknowledge only the pseudonym.

When someone is not posting on a blog, whether by their own choice or by the blog owner's choice, then, I have no problem with 'outing' the name, if it is relevant to the issue.

Your retaliatory reaction to my 'outing' you, as Fishy/If/Dawg/Baglow was unethical. And, furthermore, you do NOT post phone numbers, addresses and emails - ever - in any situation. Never. Got that?

She's right, of course, on the last bit, even if the coordinates are by now well out of date. Motive, as I said, does count. But the rest of this is, not to put too fine a point upon it, a hoot. It has to be some of the most sinuous reasoning I've ever encountered. Bishop's was lucky to have her, if only for comic relief.

I do feel the need to clear up some factual errors, though, squinting as I am through my tears of laughter. Earlier in the thread, she said that I came from the US. Really impressive research, there, Prof. And I have posted nothing on the thread at all, although she appears to believe that I am, well, "Fishy" and "If" and, for all I know, the Walrus and one of the Eggmen.

Guestblogger "lance" likely knows this very well, but he's letting it ride. That's cool. He's probably getting as much of a kick out of this as I am.

In the meantime:
ET, call home. And if you forget your number--call me. :)

UPDATE: It gets better.* The terminally outraged Taborsky bleats to one of her tormentors:

[Y]ou don't understand blogging ethics. First, I have never used my name in blogging. Not here or at the Shotgun. Always my initials. You have no right to use my personal name in this blog, or inform people of it.

And then this simply scrumptious morsel of prose; I 'm thinking of having it engraved upon the head of a pin:

Don't insult people. And don't abuse blogging ethics. Again, I have no problem with telling someone who a blogger really is - on another blog. After all, we can certainly reveal who Lewis Carroll was and discuss his work, but, if we were interacting with him as such, we wouldn't violate that trust.

For the second time in 24 hours--I got nothing.

*wipes eyes*


____________________________
*since excised, after this comment by Marky Mark.

Try not to leave a tear on your keyboard

















Kathy Shaidle is upset with me--again.


Interesting question, though, and I don't mean the pin-up genre: can we be friends with people with whom we disagree politically? I would have thought the answer was obvious--yes, of course: politics is barely more than skin-deep--but the malignant half-pint disagrees.

Comments? Personal accounts are particularly welcome.

UPDATE: The ultimate accolade.

UPPERDATE: (June 12) "
Kathy Shaidle, a Canadian wingnut of imperfect renown who attempts an expert dismount from the high horse and ends up flailing limb over limb into a folding refreshments table covered with Dixie cups of Haterade." I wish I'd said that. [H/t reader "Navvy"]

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

Annals of anti-Semitism















I got nothing.

UPDATE: (June 11) And in case you thought the above reference was an exaggeration, here's the liberal Ha'aretz:

A photo released by the White House, which shows Obama talking on the phone with Netanyahu on Monday, speaks volumes: The president is seen with his legs up on the table, his face stern and his fist clenched, as though he were dictating to Netanyahu: "Listen up and write 'Palestinian state' a hundred times. That's right, Palestine, with a P." As an enthusiast of Muslim culture, Obama surely knows there is no greater insult in the Middle East than pointing the soles of one's shoes at another person. Indeed, photos of other presidential phone calls depict Obama leaning on his desk, with his feet on the floor. [Emphases added]

On the last point, Obama (like countless others, myself included) enjoys the foot-on-the-desk informality--as did his predecessor. Showing shoe-soles is an Arab insult, not an American one or an Israeli one. So what is being broadly hinted at here? Ah, its the "enthusiast of Muslim culture" aka the "closet Muslim" meme, redivivus.

Fist clenched? With his thumb and forefinger forming a circle? Face stern, rather than merely serious? One picture might be worth a thousand words, but Ha'aretz's words have no relation to this picture at all. That such "analysis" would appear in a liberal Israeli newspaper shows just how far things have deteriorated. Maybe the following is more typical of current thinking in Israel than I had, up to now, been prepared to believe:


Death of James von Brunn 88

















"88" is the gematria of the neo-Nazi two-digit IQ set, standing for HH--Heil Hitler. Von Brunn signed off that way.

It was also the disgusting creature's age when he got himself killed shot. No doubt he was bucking for Randy Weaver-like immortality.

And he's already got it--sort of.

BACKDATE: Reader Bob LeDrew points out that von Brunn is not dead, merely in critical condition. The guard he shot at the Holocaust Museum was not so lucky. I must have been a victim of unconscious wishful thinking. Mea maxima culpa.

Out of the mouths...

















...of stepsons.

"Why does bottled water have an expiry date?"

February 20, 2011. There it was.

Google was not my friend. Suggested reasons:
  • Chemicals from the bottle leach into the water
  • It's planned obsolescence, to increase the water company's profits
  • The law says that every consumable product must show an expiry date, so the companies just pick one at random
  • The water changes taste over time
  • The water companies slip fluoride into the water, which eventually expires
And my personal fave:
  • "Water which is not flowing can go stagnant. Bacteria and even small worms can appear."
Plausible answers are welcome. I must admit that the leaching explanation sounded convincing.

In the meantime, here's The Economist, if you can believe it:


The success of bottled water is in many ways one of capitalism’s greatest mysteries. Studies show consistently that tap water is purer than many bottled waters—not including those that contain only tap water, which by some estimates is 40% of the total by volume.

OK, then. All of the above.


[H/t Danny MacKinnon].

Sado-politics: my temptation

Stories like this bring out the worst in me:

Prosecutor John Watson said Buffy, the nickname of a girl who was 16 at the time of the killing, should be sentenced as an adult for her role in the violent rape and murder of 13-year-old Nina.
--
Defence lawyer Peter Royal said the teen should be sentenced as a youth because she did not directly contribute to Nina's death or coerce her from West Edmonton Mall to the golf course.

The one stab wound Buffy did inflict was deep, but not life-threatening, Royal said. [Emphasis added]


UPDATE: (June 17) Buffy gets a break.

The Raitt tapes: oil and wind

Well, well, well--as it were.

That Raitt recording is truly the gift that goes on giving. Seems that her comments about the isotope shortage were mere frosting on the cake.

This is not trivial:


Money earmarked to support wind energy producers was diverted to research and development in the oil patch in backroom budget wrangling, the minister of natural resources said in a conversation with an aide in January.

Lisa Raitt told aide Jasmine MacDonnell that she suspects Environment Minister Jim Prentice took the money for wind power and redirected it to his Clean Energy Plan – a $1-billion fund for research and development in the oil sands.
--
Mr. Prentice's office refused to comment on the recording on Tuesday, and the minister's office told reporters he would end a media question and answer session on Wednesday if anybody asked him about the recording.


What's that noise? Could it be...the sound of more shoes dropping? Heads rolling? Both?

[H/t Buckets]

Two tales, three dogs

Nothing wrong with juxtaposition, just so long as you don't make a fetish of it.

May 21, 2009: Police officers who shot two dogs running loose cleared of wrongdoing

Zappia and Priori have said they were walking the dogs — Mika, a two-year-old husky, and Azzurro, a three-year-old German shorthaired pointer — off-leash in a wooded area behind the Emerald Links golf course when the dogs caught sight of a deer and chased after it. They were trying to find the dogs in the area at the time of the shooting, and Zappia came upon the scene just as an officer shot Azzurro.

Zappia’s father has since given the couple two new puppies, but the loss of Mika and Azzurro is still keenly felt.


June 10, 2009:
Man who shot RCMP dog thought it was a stray

An Alberta man who fatally shot an RCMP breeding dog says he fired his shotgun because the German shepherd was chasing his cat.

Robert Adams of the Caroline area was on trial on charges of causing death or injury to an animal and unauthorized possession of a firearm.

Adams admitted to police that he shot the dog named Nyla on Aug. 16, 2007.

He said he thought Nyla, a breeding dog for the RCMP's Police Dog Training Centre near Innisfail, was a dangerous stray.

His lawyer said in rural Alberta farmers have the right to shoot animals, such as dogs, if they are harassing livestock.

Judge Darrell Riemer said he would issue his verdict at a later date.

Tuesday, June 09, 2009

How sweet it is

"Although the Liberals are well behind the NDP, which is leading or elected in 31 districts, the Grits are in a tough fight with the Progressive Conservatives for Official Opposition status."

For one joyous moment, one imagines Iggy battling it out with Stephen after their Dion Memorial Coalition is soundly rejected by the Canadian electorate. One can dream.

By the way, we're way past 50 now.

Just to save them the trouble...

...since the proverbial cat seems to have got their tongues, I've taken the liberty of making their comments on Raitt-gate for them.

1) I see that the Liberals and the NDP are making a lot of noise about my friend the Honourable Lisa Raitt. She didn't do anything wrong and how many of them don't talk like that in private. I am proud of HMPM Stephen Harper for standing up against these bulies.

2) The compassionate left...standing in line to attack women. What I gotta know is...are they envious or just being themselves...or is there a difference?

3) As if the Liberals never had their asshole hands in the cookiejar and said some things they would regret if their enemies dropped documents and tapes all over the fricken place. Why don't they all just die.

4) The Liberals are at it again and the Old Media, I solemnly accuse, is a willing, co-conspiring (yes, conspiring!) party to another treasonous attack of unprecedented historic magnitude. Think I'm nuts to be saying this stuff? Prove it.

5) Lisa Raitt was always against the kangaroo courts called human rights commissions, where free speech is regularly silenced, rules of evidence don't exist, and complainants get an all-expenses-paid ride while respondents are faced with crippling costs. I'm still on the road, selling my book by the barrow-load yesterday to admiring crowds in Carp, Ontario. I have to admire the young fellow who drove in from Ottawa to shake my hand warmly and tell me he wanted to see Human Rights Commissions abolished outright, and something done about galloping Islamism in Canada. Tomorrow I'm a guest of the Royal Canadian Legion in Pakenham.

6) I will be on Right Radio on Tuesday, talking about the lawsuits against me and my fellow-bloggers, and my new book. Mark Steyn will be calling in briefly. Who's Lisa Raitt, anyway?


No, no prizes. Too easy.

UPDATE: More from CC.

The Braidwood Chronicles: RCMP end-run?





















The unmitigated torrent of RCMP sleaze continues.

Those who have been following the twists and turns of the Braidwood Inquiry into the killing of Robert Dziekanski by RCMP officers don't, as they say, need a weatherman to know which way the wind has been blowing. The officers have made a spectacle of themselves, lying in perfect unison, wriggling and dancing on the stand. There were further attempts made to smear the reputation of their victim, with one mouthpiece attempting to bring decades-old records into evidence. There was a last-ditch attempt, using a questionable "expert," to tell us that we didn't see what we saw when we viewed and reviewed the Pritchard video.

There had been false statements given to the media. There had been a cover-up lasting for months. There had been evidence of rot from the very top, as Commissioner William "Bubbles" Elliott (and BC Premier Gordon Campbell), publicly contrite, sent private words of encouragement to the officers while Dziekanski's mother was still raw with grief.

It has been a sickening tale.

Think it couldn't get any worse? Oh, ye of little faith. If there's a dark corner to crawl into, the RCMP will assuredly find it. And so this morning we learn that the RCMP lawyers have gone to the British Columbia Supreme Court to head off the Braidwood Inquiry, asking it to enjoin Justice Braidwood from making any findings of misconduct against the Four Horsemen.

That would be improper, says David Butcher, the lawyer for Constable Bill Bentley. The Inquiry is provincial. The officers come under federal jurisdiction.


Is this yet another straw being grasped by that sorry gang of ill-trained cowboys, drowning in their sea of lies and excuses--or is it a lifebuoy? Only time will tell. Because w
e always seem to have a ready supply of the latter when police misbehaviour is dragged, squinting, into the light.

Monday, June 08, 2009

Reflections on Raitt-gate

When all was said and done, the tapes really didn't carry the KA-BOOM punch that we political opponents lusted for--did they? Let's climb down a few rungs and admit it. Sum total: a Minister said some unkind but possibly true things about another Minister. And she used the word "sexy" to describe a situation that she confidently expected to fix and to reap mucho limelight and credit for so doing.

Answer me this: in the privacy of your office, or even in the theatre of your own thoughts, have you ever said something unflattering about a colleague, or cackled with joyous expectation when the prospect of capitalizing on an unexpected situation has presented itself? Or, put more positively, have all your private words and thoughts been articulated in a form that would pass public inspection? If so, by all means throw your stone---although it obviously won't be the first.

Our main concern shouldn't be this frankly trivial stuff. (Spare me the torrents of false outrage: I know something about cancer, as some regulars here are aware, and I can't find anything in the Minister's remarks that makes light of it.) We're missing the boat, people. Schadenfreude is all very well--I'm an addict, actually--but let's aim that emotion at the right target.

The issue here isn't what a light and lively Minister said to a subordinate. Rather, it's the obscene and crazy lengths that the Harper regime went to in order to cover up this paltry instance of vanity and gracelessness. (Anyone still believing that this was an heroically unselfish act on the part of an ex-staffer, acting alone to save the tattered reputation of the high-living flibbertigibbet who had just finished underbussing her, is--to put it charitably--a gull.)

An injunction was sought, of unprecedented sweep, not only to squelch a news story, but even the identity of the person who was acting as point person for the squelchers. It was just the latest example of the thuggishness, and the ruthless assumption of unassailable sovereignty, that have become hallmarks of this government. In fact, the very contentlessness of the revelations demonstrate just how far things have gone.

Let's keep our eye on the ball. The issue is not a vainglorious Minister with a taste for fame, perks and expensive lunches. It's not even, in this instance, her cover-up of the full magnitude of the Chalk River fiasco. The issue is a government that proceeds under the confident assumption that it should be able to do whatever it wants.

It's a government that goes to court to argue that a Canadian citizen can be exiled by ministerial fiat. It's a government that insists that it has no obligation to any Canadian citizen outside our borders. It's a government that, from on high, revokes a training grant because a Minister has been called a name. It's a government that has allowed Border Security to screen the political opinions to which we might be exposed. And now it's a government that has just tried to drop the hammer on freedom of the press to spare itself--what? A little embarrassment?

Of course, this has backfired badly. Now the whole matter has become amplified a thousandfold, like a certain sexual act performed upon a former President of the United States. Of no moment in itself, it has become supercharged by the measures taken to suppress the public knowledge of it.

But surely, as noted, it is the very willingness to resort to those measures in the first place that truly merits our attention and our censure. Minister Raitt and her hapless underling are by now merely collateral damage inflicted by the government upon itself. Let's finish the job, and not allow ourselves to be diverted.

Harper tries to shut down the press [updated]

In breaking news, the Harper government is trying to block the publication of a story that would prove embarrassing to the already-embattled Minister of Natural Resources, Lisa Raitt, aka "The Chalk River Leak." The junketing Raitt, of course, is no stranger to bully-tactics of this kind.

Stay tuned. This could get ugly. But what about this government isn't?


[H/t James Bowie and Pushed to the left]

UPDATE: Heh. Once again, bloggers are ahead of the curve.

UPPERDATE: The Conservatives cut and run:

Dimitri Soudas, press secretary to Prime Minister Stephen Harper, said no government department is involved in the hearing in Nova Scotia on Monday afternoon. Soudas said he had no knowledge of the matter. Steve Outhouse, who has replaced MacDonnell as Raitt's director of communications, also said his office had no knowledge of the matter.

Ryan Sparrow, a spokesman for the Conservative Party of Canada, said the party has no connection to the matter.

In unrelated news, land sales in Florida are on the rise, and a large bridge to New York City is up for auction on e-Bay with no reserve price.

(As an aside, there's something quite charming about a communications director sporting the name "Outhouse," don't you think? High school must have been a torment for the lad.)

UPPESTDATE: Hah! Injunction denied.

EVEN UPPIER: And now, the story you've all been waiting for. Meanwhile, the hard cases at Small Dead Animals think the whole thing is a Lib'rul plot. And Liberal commenter Ted is happy to point out just how devilishly clever it was.

[H/t POGGE and CC]

Steakholders
















Here's the latest on Minister Lisa Raitt's high-rolling ways as CEO of the Toronto Port Authority. And her team, it seems, were no slackers either. Four TPA board members are talking:


They said management spent $50,000 at a steakhouse, and that one lunch cost nearly $1,000, approved their own expenses and spent an unnecessary amount of time in England on the Port Authority's dime. [emphasis added]

And the ministerial stain spreads.

More Iggy flexi-speak




















Get used to it.

This time it's the Conservatives' sado-political bill to impose mandatory sentences on drug dealers, something that most expert witnesses before the parliamentary Committee on Justice and Human Rights have testified would be a disaster. But punishment, not deterrence, has always been the Cons' thing.

And the Liberals, as usual, are tamely going along.

"In the context of some occasions where the sentences have not been appropriate, we're in support of C-15," said Ignatieff, who was at the Federation of Canadian Municipalities conference in Whistler, B.C.

"We support stronger measures, but there isn't one hammer to this problem. We have to have federal investments in innovation and treatment and services in order to deal with these problems."

Shorter Iggy: We're in favour, but we aren't in favour. The legislation will work, but it won't. Whatever.

Sunday, June 07, 2009

Weekend outing





















My co-blogger alerted me to this story south of the border, wanting to know if I had any comments on it.

She must have known how conflicted I'd be. I'm not averse to the outing of bloggers and trolls
when the occasion calls for it, not to mention out-and-out criminals, and exposing neo-Nazis (for example, the British National Party faithful) is simply a public service. But there are, as for all things, parameters.

I blog under a pseudonym, but as I've remarked before, it's more a nom-de-plume than a disguise, and anyone who wants to know who I "really" am need spend a mere 10 seconds on Google. There are others, however, for whom anonymity is a necessity, for a number of reasons outlined here. What Ed Whelan did was cowardly, reprehensible, and (one lives in hope) actionable.

Whom would I out, if I had my druthers and a sudden absence of judgement? Where would I personally draw the line? I dunno. I think I'd begin, though, with those who believe they have "outed" me, imagining they're so all-fired clever when doing so, while cowering behind their own masks the while. That's on-line hypocrisy, a cardinal sin to be smote where she is wrote.

I'd put the simpering "Raphael Alexander" in that category (although frankly I'd prefer in his case to keep him as an on-going object lesson) and, if it weren't for the real danger it might place him in, the libelous nuclear physicist who blogs under the name of "shlemazl." Turnabout is fair play. I wept no tears when "Blazing Cat Fur" was outed. Same reason.

But in general, outing somebody simply because you don't like their point of view, or because you don't like being criticized by them, is an act of petty vengeance. No, not always petty. In this case, Whelan had advance notice that this could compromise his opponent's job and the security of his family. He decided to go ahead anyway, vicious wingnut that he is.
And here's one of his despicable fellows, hoping out loud that Whelan's target loses his university position [h/t Garry Wise]. That's how they roll.

Question for the day, in any case: is "outing" a blogger or commenter ever justified? If so, under what conditions? Comments welcome.

UPDATE: (June 8) More on Whelan v. "Publius" from Simon of Bloggasm.

UPPERDATE: (June 9) Whelan has apologized.

Saturday, June 06, 2009

Old hatreds, new politics and Mikhail Lennikov

A family is being torn apart as old ethnic conflicts, Conservative politics and the ghost of the Cold War have caught Mikhail Lennikov in their toils.

Lennikov is presently in sanctuary, trying to avoid deportation to Russia, which was scheduled this past Wednesday. As a young man in 1982, he joined the Russian secret police (the KGB), quitting (or being dismissed) in 1988. He claims to have been recruited against his will, and that his resignation was not well-received by the KGB, which began to threaten him. In 1997 he brought his family to Canada, and in 1999 applied for permanent residency, disclosing to immigration officials that he had worked for the KGB. In 2002, he was told that he--and his family--were inadmissible for that reason.

"There is sufficient credible and trustworthy evidence to conclude that Lennikov was complicit in acts of espionage during his years as an active KGB member," wrote lead member Irene Dicaire in a 2006 decision that Lennikov has been fighting ever since.

"It is my view that Lennikov was trying to downplay his true role and to hide his real goal," she said.

He worked as a Japanese translator, he says, not daring to turn down the KGB's request that he join the organization, but the Immigration and Refugee Board claims that he collected information on visiting Japanese businessmen. There is no reason to disbelieve this, but bumping that up to the level of "espionage" raised my eyebrows a bit. His job appears to have been similar to the shadowing of some foreign visitors by our very own CSIS, whose doings have been in the news recently. Indeed, he left Russia in 1995 to live in Japan for two years before arriving here.

His family, just a few weeks ago, received preliminary permission to stay in Canada on humanitarian grounds, sparing the bright young Dmitri Lennikov, who has just graduated high school with distinction, the possibility of being drafted into the Russian military.

There is a good background summation of the case here by the CBC's Terry Milewski. It does not reflect well on the current government. Public Safety Minister Peter Van Loan has been oddly evasive regarding the reasons for its decision, which appear to have been based at least in part upon an error-laced briefing note from Stephen Rigby, the head of the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA).

But there may be more to this than one flawed memorandum.

Lubomyr Luciuk, a Ukrainian nationalist (to put it mildly), has been aggressively campaigning to have Lennikov deported. Luciuk, a professor at the Royal Military College
, and the director of research for the Ukrainian Canadian Civil Liberties Association, has been at this sort of thing for a while.

He was in the news in 2005, engaging in a public spat with the head of the Canadian Jewish Congress, Bernie Farber. A number of Ukrainians worked with the Nazis, and Luciuk has been somewhat defensive on that score. He jumped to the support of John Demjanjuk, for example, now facing trial in Germany for complicity in the deaths of 29,000 people, and he has been a fierce advocate for Wasyl Odynsky, a former guard at the Trawniki and Poniatowa forced labour camps, who lied his way into Canada. (In 2007, the Harper Cabinet, for reasons best known to themselves, cut Odynsky a break and let him remain in the country.)

Luciuk has publicly mocked the search for Nazi war criminals in Canada (scroll down), and in 2005 urged the prosecution of four Russian nationals instead. According to the
Globe and Mail's Kirk Makin, "Mr. Luciuk said it is a complete coincidence that the four individuals who have been targeted for attention are Jewish."

Add this, too, to the simmering stew of inter-ethnic conflict and Cold War memories: Harper's Conservative Party has been waging a battle for the hearts and minds of Canada's various immigrant communities for years. It moved to gain Ukrainian-Canadian support in 2004 by offering compensation for ill-treatment by the Canadian government during the First World War. Meanwhile, Liberal leader Michael Ignatieff, Russian by extraction, has been targeted by members of the Ukrainian community since 2005.

And caught in the midst of all of these forces far beyond his control, Mikhail Lennikov is about to see his life destroyed.


All fourteen of you perished....
[We] enter the kitchen to find there
one more broken cadaver, its black eyes beadily staring
...We had felt no talent to murder,
it was against our pluck. Why, why then? For raisons d'État. As
householders we had behaved exactly as every State does,
when there is something it wants, and a minor one gets in the way.

--W.H. Auden, "Talking to Mice"

Friday, June 05, 2009

Another chickenhawk heard from

This time it's the vulgar semi-journalist Earl McRae, horking about the "treasonous imbecility" of those of us in the Ottawa area opposed to the use of city property for death bazaars.

Hah, big brave McRae's right in there fighting with the troops:

My first father fought in World War II and died. My uncle fought in World War II and died. My second father fought in World War II, my grandfather fought in World War I. They fought with what all Canadian soldiers fought with: Military weapons that -- thank God -- somebody manufactured.

Oh, wait a minute--that was members of his family. McRae himself expresses his bravery in a somewhat different manner. He calls people names in a column.

By that measure, he's a gutsy fellow, all right. Here he is in 2006:

I thought of you, Jack Layton. I thought of you and all your other left-wing lollipops who want to bring our brave and committed soldiers home from Afghanistan because you can't stomach that some of them are getting killed -- I thought of you because with your self-righteous intellectual arrogance and colossal stupidity, you just don't get it, and never will.

Earl McRae, hero, but somehow manqué. I've met his type before. Happy to pack our young men and women off to be killed in a war we cannot win--but likely to wet his manly drawers if someone looked at him sideways in a bar. Buck-buck-bacaw.

Shovel ready

The lash of Justice Russel Zinn’s judgement in the Abdelrazik case may not be felt by its target. The Conservatives at this point seem to be twitching in their political death throes: only a few ideological tremors remain.

For some time, in fact, this government seems to have abandoned strategy altogether. Its moves are ill-thought-out, arbitrary and dangerous: spur-of-the-moment abuses of power. No thought appears to have been given to their public policy consequences.

In the case of Abdelrazik, the illegal exile of a Canadian citizen was stoutly defended by government lawyers, whose main argument was that Minister Lawrence Cannon’s decision could not be reviewed by a court. The rule of law, they were forced to claim, was no longer operative: the Minister was duly exercising what amounts to a sovereign authority--somewhat of a setback for the principle of responsible government, had it been upheld.

By itself, this might be dismissed as a freakish occurrence. But in fact it’s just part of a disturbing pattern. There's the on-going saga of Omar Khadr, which began as shameless pandering to the Conservative base and to the darker instincts to be found in the ranks of the Canadian electorate. The government apparently felt that it was on safe ground, steadfastly refusing to repatriate a young Canadian citizen from that zone of exception known as Guantanamo. He had been accused of terrorism, after all, and was a Muslim. Case closed.

There is by now considerable doubt that Khadr actually did what he has been accused of, and there is evidence as well that he has been tortured in captivity. The judicial process under which he is being "tried" is a bad joke. He was, under international convention, a child soldier at the time he was captured. All other Western countries have repatriated their own nationals. But the government remains firm, despite every new revelation.

Although one cannot ignore the implicit racism and Islamophobia in the government's intransigence, of more importance are the serious policy consequences of its refusal to repatriate Khadr. It has reached the point, in fact--having lost a court battle and been told to take appropriate repatriation measures--that the government has now painted itself into a corner, forced to argue on appeal that it has no responsibility for any Canadian citizens outside our territorial borders.

That is an astonishing and yet inevitable turn of events. Having dug in, the government must now defend the indefensible, as it did in the Abdelrazik case. Our passports, according to the Harper regime, are of dubious worth if we ever get into a jam abroad. Foreign Affairs doesn't have to lift a finger--and if your skin is the wrong colour, or you worship the wrong God, it likely won't.

On the home front, the government has flagrantly attacked the rule of law, interfered in the operations of "arms-length" Crown agencies, corrupted our political culture, eroded our cultural institutions, and undercut a supposedly independent parliamentary watchdog. At the same time, it has engaged in a fiscally stimulative exercise to purchase Liberal support, thereby
hacking away at its own base.*

I can discern no planning in any of this, no strategy, as I noted before. The rational actor model simply doesn't apply. It's brain-dead government by nervous reflex. (Hey, let's all go out and sue a terrorist!)

Come on, Liberals, enough with the heroic measures. Time to pull the plug and give this regime a decent burial. It's the right thing to do.


__________________
*They needn't have worried: the Liberals, as under Stéphane Dion, remain its staunchest allies, recently embracing the former's brutally primitive law-and-order agenda, for example, and earlier voting with the Cons to abolish pay equity. The Libs also supported a substantial grant of taxpayers' money to the Chrysotile Institute, which shills for the deadly asbestos industry.

безродный космополит





















I have at long last been exposed as a "rootless cosmopolite." I should have seen this coming. As far back as March, an anti-Semitic hack from the West Coast attacked my "Zionist NDP blog." The dogs had begun to bark.

Well I remember the latter days of Stalinism, and the denunciations that flowed against citizens of the world like myself,


unbridled, evil-minded cosmopolitans, profiteers with no roots and no conscience… Grown on rotten yeast of bourgeois cosmopolitanism, decadence and formalism… non-indigenous nationals without a motherland, who poison with stench… our proletarian culture. --"About one antipatriotic group of theater critics," Pravda, January 28, 1949

Occasionally, pundits like F. Chernov went too far:

Appearing as messengers and propagandists for bourgeois ideology, the rootless-cosmopolitans fawned over and groveled before decadent bourgeois culture. Defaming Soviet socialist culture, they praised to the heavens that which was found in the emaciated and decayed conditions of bourgeois culture. In the great culture of the Russian people they saw echos and rehashings of Western bourgeois culture.

I must chide Comrade Chernov here. A little decadence, like salt in a stew, goes a long way. No rootless cosmopolite can live on salt alone.

At length, in any case, the official denunciation came. In a stroke of genius, I was condemned, not by a heroic proletarian defender of the Motherland, but by a commenter at the blogsite of someone posing as anti-Communist, Russian and Jewish. That, Comrades Stalin and Chernov, if I may say so, outdoes your relatively feeble efforts at curbing dangerous cosmopolitan tendencies. To be denounced as a rootless cosmopolite in the very home of another notorious rootless cosmopolite carries its additional sting:

There are rootless intellectuals like this Dr. Dawg fellow who move from country to country, acquire different citizenships, but pride themselves on their sense of detachment and look condescendingly on those who have a strong sense of attachment, heritage, family history and feel it's their prerogative to completely reengineer and redefine the social relationships in this country, to throw open our borders and call anyone and everyone a Canadian, irrespective of whether they want to be, what they identify themselves as, whether they have any attachment and commitment to this country.

Like Ilya Ehrenberg, I now numbly await the knock on the door.

Thursday, June 04, 2009

Abdelrazik: stunning setback for the Harper regime



















Federal appeal court judge Russel Zinn, in a landmark ruling, has ordered the Harper government to repatriate the exiled Abousfian Abdelrazik within thirty days. And, in an unusual move, he has remained seized of the case. If a ticket has not been arranged for Abdelrazik in fifteen days, said Zinn, he may drag the government before him to explain why.

The judge did not mince words:

“Mr. Abdelrazik's Charter right to enter Canada has been breached by the respondents... Mr. Abdelrazik is entitled to an appropriate remedy which, in the unique circumstances of his situation, requires that the Canadian government take immediate action so that Mr. Abdelrazik is returned to Canada.''

The judge said that keeping Mr. Abdelrazik in forced exiled means he is “as much a victim of international terrorism as the innocent persons whose lives have been taken by recent barbaric acts of terrorists.''

Will the outrageous antics of the Harper government stop here--or will it pursue its vendetta against this dark-skinned Canadian by seeking leave to appeal to the Supreme Court?

Well, whatever Harper and his ministers eventually decide in their dank little burrows, I--and countless other Canadians, including, I expect, Abdelrazik himself, and his long-suffering family--will be celebrating tonight. This ruling, the no-nonsense clarity of which I did not dare to expect, was a major blow struck for civil liberties, the rule of law, and Canadian values of decency and fairness. Zinn's hard-hitting decision makes me proud beyond measure at this point to be Abdelrazik's fellow citizen.

UPDATE: A clear, uncompromising, straight to the point and frequently witty judgement. Some excerpts:


There is no direct evidence before this Court that Mr. Abdelrazik supports, financially or otherwise, is a member of, or follows the principles of Al-Qaida. There is no evidence before this Court as to the basis on which the United States authorities concluded that Mr. Abdelrazik has provided support to Al-Qaida and poses a threat to the security of the United States of America. There is no evidence before this Court nor, as shall be discussed later, that is currently available to Mr. Abdelrazik as to the basis on which the 1267 Committee listed him as an associate of Al-Qaida. The only direct evidence before this Court is in an affidavit filed by Mr. Abdelrazik in which he swears that he has no connection to Al-Qaida. (11)

Counsel for the applicant met with officials from Foreign Affairs on February 27, 2008, to discuss his client’s situation. In a letter dated April 18, 2008, the Director of Consular Case Management for Foreign Affairs wrote as follows:

With respect to Mr. Abdelrazik’s passport application, I would like
to remind you of our commitment, expressed in our meeting of
February 27, to ensure that he has an emergency travel document to
facilitate his return to Canada. We stand by that commitment.
(emphasis added)

Passport Canada falls under the jurisdiction of the Minister of Foreign Affairs. (13)

I add my name to those who view the 1267 Committee regime as a denial of basic legal remedies and as untenable under the principles of international human rights. There is nothing in the listing or de-listing procedure that recognizes the principles of natural justice or that provides for basic procedural fairness. Unlike the first Canadian security certificate scheme that was rejected by the Supreme Court in Charkaoui v. Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration), 2007 SCC 9; [2007] 1 S.C.R. 350, the 1267 Committee listing and de-listing processes do not even include a limited right to a hearing. It can hardly be said that the 1267 Committee process meets the requirement of independence and impartiality when, as appears may be the case involving Mr. Abdelrazik, the nation requesting the listing is one of the members of the body that decides whether to list or, equally as important, to de-list a person. The accuser is also the judge.(22)

It is difficult to see what information any petitioner could provide to prove a negative, i.e. to prove that he or she is not associated with Al-Qaida. One cannot prove that fairies and goblins do not exist any more than Mr. Abdelrazik or any other person can prove that they are not an Al-Qaida associate. It is a fundamental principle of Canadian and international justice that the accused does not have the burden of proving his innocence, the accuser has the burden of proving guilt. In light of these shortcomings, it is disingenuous of the respondents to submit, as they did, that if he is wrongly listed the remedy is for Mr. Abdelrazik to apply to the 1267 Committee for de-listing and not to engage this Court. The 1267 Committee regime is, as I observed at the hearing, a situation for a listed person not unlike that of Josef K. in Kafka’s The Trial, who awakens one morning and, for reasons never revealed to him or the reader, is arrested and prosecuted for an unspecified crime. (23-24)

I pause to comment that it is frightening to learn that a citizen of this or any other country might find himself on the 1267 Committee list, based only on suspicion. (24)

An allegation that Canada was complicit in a foreign nation detaining a Canadian citizen is very serious, particularly when no charges are pending against him and in circumstances where he had previously fled that country as a Convention refugee. However, in my view, the evidence before the Court establishes, on the balance of probabilities, that the recommendation for the detention of Mr. Abdelrazik by Sudan came either directly or indirectly from CSIS. I find, on the balance of probabilities, on the record before the Court, that CSIS was complicit in the initial detention of Mr. Abdelrazik by the Sudanese.(38)

The applicant relies on a statement contained in Case Note 123 dated July 30, 2004, authored by Ms. Gaudet-Fee of Foreign Affairs in Ottawa as evidence of the “attitude” of Foreign Affairs and, he submits, it proves that there was never any real intention to have him returned to Canada. The impugned statement is as follows:

So, should she get a private plane, there is very little we could do to
stop him from entering Canada. He would need an EP [i.e.
Emergency Passport] and I guess this could be refused but on what
ground.
So, stay tuned. (43)

Although no emergency passport was asked for, as the private flight failed to materialize, I find the comment of the official of Foreign Affairs very troubling. I find the respondents’ explanation less than convincing. Admittedly the statement was made shortly after Foreign Affairs found out about the no-fly listing and also learned, for the first time it appears, that Mr. Abdelrazik was alleged to have connections to Al-Qaida. Neither fact explains why a Canadian official of foreign Affairs would be musing about refusing Mr. Abdelrazik an emergency passport. (44)

The applicant submits that he had previously been told by Canadian officials that an emergency passport would issue if he secured an itinerary but that following this potential flight, the respondents changed the goal-posts, requiring him to have a paid itinerary before an emergency passport would issue.

There is support for this submission.The word “paid” is added to the assurances from Canadian officials only after this event. The first such reference is in a letter to applicant’s counsel dated December 23, 2008 from the Director General Security Bureau, Passport Canada....

It was Canada’s view that it was illegal under the 1822 Resolution and the laws of Canada to financially assist Mr. Abdelrazik. Canada was also aware that he was impecunious. It is not unreasonable to suggest, as the applicant did, that in adding the condition that the itinerary be a paid one, Canada was ensuring that it would not be called upon to provide the emergency passport. The applicant submits that this added condition is further evidence that Canada never intended to permit him to return to Canada. The weight of the evidence supports that submission. (49)

[T]he respondents’ interpretation of the 1267 travel ban leads to a nonsensical result. According to their interpretation, the Resolution permits a citizen to enter Canada if and only if he happens to be standing at the Canadian border crossing, but it prevents that same citizen from reaching that border crossing as he cannot transit over land or through air to reach it. On the respondents’ interpretation the exemption that provides that no State is obliged to prevent its citizens from entry becomes meaningless as there is virtually no possibility that a listed person will be located at a border crossing and there is no possibility under current technology that he will be
able to simply transport himself to the border crossing without transiting over land or through the air. Quite simply that could not have been the intention of the drafters of the Resolution. (52)

In my view, the submission that the applicant had not been denied entry into Canada by the Government of Canada was not accurate when made 6 days after the Minister had denied the applicant an emergency passport. Whether or not the Etihad Airways flight scheduled for April 3, 2009 would breach the travel ban set out in the 1822 Resolution, there is no evidence before the Court that had Mr. Abdelrazik been in possession of an emergency passport issued by Canada that he would not have been on that flight and now in Canada. I find that the only reason that Mr. Abdelrazik is not in Canada now is because of the actions of the Minister on April 3, 2009. (62)

In my view, where a citizen is outside Canada, the Government of Canada has a positive obligation to issue an emergency passport to that citizen to permit him or her to enter Canada; otherwise, the right guaranteed by the Government of Canada in subsection 6(1) of the Charter is illusory. Where the Government refuses to issue that emergency passport, it is a prima facie breach of the citizen’s Charter rights unless the Government justifies its
refusal pursuant to section 1 of the Charter. (64)

I find that the applicant’s Charter right as a citizen of Canada to enter Canada has been breached by the respondents in failing to issue him an emergency passport. In my view, it is not necessary to decide whether that breach was done in bad faith; a breach, whether made in bad faith or good faith remains a breach and absent justification under section 1 of the Charter, the aggrieved party is entitled to a remedy. Had it been necessary to determine whether the breach was done in bad faith, I would have had no hesitation making that finding on the basis of the record before me. (64-5)

It is simply not sufficient for the Minister to say that he has reached this opinion and “trust me” – he must show more; he must establish that it was “required”. While it is not the function of the judiciary to second guess or to substitute its opinion for that of the Minister, when no basis is provided for the opinion, the Court cannot find that the refusal was required and justified given the significant breach of the Charter that refusing a passport to a Canadian citizen entails. In this case, the refusal of the emergency passport effectively leaves Mr. Abdelrazik as a prisoner in a foreign land, consigned to live the remainder of his life in the Canadian Embassy or leave and risk detention and torture. (67)

I have found that Canada has engaged in a course of conduct and specific acts that constitute a breach of Mr. Abdelrazik’s right to enter Canada. Specifically, I find:

(i) That CSIS was complicit in the detention of Mr. Abdelrazik by the Sudanese authorities in 2003;
(ii) That by mid 2004 Canadian authorities had determined that they would not take any active steps to assist Mr. Abdelrazik to return to Canada and, in spite of its numerous assurances to the contrary, would consider refusing him an emergency passport if that was required in order to ensure that he could not return to Canada;
(iii) That there is no impediment from the UN Resolution to Mr. Abdelrazik being repatriated to Canada – no permission of a foreign government is required to transit through its airspace – and the respondents’ assertion to the contrary is a part of the conduct engaged in to ensure that Mr. Abdelrazik could not return to Canada; and
(iv) That Canada’s denial of an emergency passport on April 3, 2009, after all of the preconditions for the issuance of an emergency passport previously set by Canada had been met, is a breach of his Charter right to enter Canada, and it has not been shown to be saved under section 1 of the Charter. (68)

I agree with the respondents that a Court should not go further than required when fashioning a remedy for a Charter breach: Doucet-Boudreau v. Nova Scotia (Minister of Education), [2003] 3 S.C.R. 3. In this case, the applicant is entitled to be put back to the place he would have been but for the breach – in Montreal. (68)

It is further required, in the Court’s judgment that the Court satisfy itself that Mr. Abdelrazik has in fact returned to Canada. Accordingly, in fulfilment of this judicial process, the Court requires that Mr. Abdelrazik attend before it at the time and date specified in the Judgment. (71) [specified later in the judgement as July 7]

There are mere smackdowns--and then there are judgements like Justice Russel Zinn's. Truly a thing of beauty.

Wednesday, June 03, 2009

Justice delayed...



...is not always justice denied.

"We need all the info we can gather lol"

















The government's case against Mohamed Harkat isn't going so well.

CSIS is under the lens, and, to extend the metaphor, the sun is getting brighter. Federal Court Justice Simon Noël is unsatisfied with its promise to investigate itself, after damaging revelations last week about CSIS' attempts to pervert the course of justice. He's holding his own behind-closed-doors inquiry.

A government lawyer has conceded the blindingly obvious: "It may be the allegations against Mr. Harkat look a little different after we're finished with the closed hearing."

Meanwhile the Canadian Border Services Agency's little fishing expedition last month is also coming under uncomfortable scrutiny. 13 agents tumbled the Harkat residence for six hours, accompanied by three police officers and three specialized sniffer dogs--one detects explosives, another, firearms, and the third can nose out money. I'd like one of those.

The posse didn't find any of the three, and had to make do, inter alia, with family photos, a newspaper article and a birth certificate.

An email from Jasmine Richard (CBSA supervisor) said: ''I need you guys to plan [referring to a home search]. We are preparing to write the risk assessments and we need all the info. we can gather lol.''

Apparently Harkat's spouse didn't see the humour, and, according to Richard, "had to be calmed down." Just another day in a country I used to recognize.

Afghanistan realism

Shorter General Stanley McChrystal: killing Afghan civilians in large numbers might just turn the people against us.

You think?

The latest "mistake," according to the US, resulted in 20-30 civilian deaths. (Hamid Karzai says 140: Charlie McCarthy, it seems, is talking back.)

McChrystal is hunkering down for a long-haul counterinsurgency assignment. What would happen if America (and presumably its allies) lost in Afghanistan? "I don't believe that the Taliban would take over Afghanistan; I think it would go back to what it was before 2001, and that would be an ongoing civil war between different factions."

Why stay?
"I believe that Al Qaeda would have the ability to move back into Afghanistan, and I cannot imagine why they would not do that." Gosh, nothing about little girls going to school.

Meanwhile, the government of Taliban Steve is supporting peace talks.

Tuesday, June 02, 2009

Pay attention.

Stay calm. Be brave. Wait for the signs.

And I would add, pay attention when another Progressive Blogger asks you to follow a news story.

From Crazy Bitches R Us:
Now a severe flu, likely the H1N1 has hit a First Nation. As you can see in this story, the First Nation only hatched together a pandemic plan after ths flu hit. Why? Well, it's difficult for a First Nation to pull together a pandemic plan, not only because of the lack of health services and professionals, but because jurisdictional disputes between federal departments (Health Canada and INAC) and between federal and provincial/territorial governments as well. These disputes prevent First Nations from accessing health care at the best of times.

Go to the blogsite, read the whole post, (which includes a news item from Manitoba) and please do as the author requested: write to your MP even if she or he is not a member of Stephen Harper's government.

The CBC also has the news item.

Sex with ducks



Kathy Shaidle's worst nightmare? Bring it on!

[H/t Pat Robertson, sort of, via John Cross]

Monday, June 01, 2009

Deep pockets















...these developers have. Deep enough to hold most of Ottawa City Council, looks like.

Violent settlers: Israel's shock troops in action

Yet more violence by the colonizers of Palestine, who, as you can see from the photo of another incident above, know how to party. Some might call it terrorism, but that's only what the other side does.

Note, buried in the story, two partial sentences:

The attackers fled and no arrests were made

and

Israeli paramilitary police stood in the background


What--you were expecting the police to interfere with Israeli state policy? "Unauthorized outposts," no. Authorized outposts? Coming soon to a Palestinian village near you.


[H/t psa]

George Tiller














All of us are pro-life
, even suicides, even killers. We celebrate life in ways large and small simply by living.

Some take joy in love; others in hate; still others may never experience the full intensity of either. Life is something we do in one way or another.

And we use words, and glances, and gestures, and touches, to signal to others that we live--and that, no matter what, we cannot live without those others. At least, we cannot live well without those others.

The suicide wants to leave life behind by an act of supreme violence, but in that very act affirms life, makes us see for a moment what he or she has left behind. At the same time we resent the suicide for abandoning the life that the rest of us live. Condemned to live, the suicide might reply. No, it's not like that for most of us. We just live.

The killer wants to live without you. There are too many reasons. Like the suicide, the killer affirms life in the very act of taking it. Once again we become aware, we give our attention not to the killer but to what the killer has stolen.

The killer and the suicide are twins.

In our number there are those who make the very act of life a thing. How does one do that?

First steal the word, deny it to others. If you are "pro-life" then others are not.

Then attack those others with words. Contrive persons where none have come into being, reject the persons who are present.
Call us killers for making difficult, sometimes agonizing choices. Call us killers when we support those who make the choices in anguish.

Post pictures of flesh and of blood, because you cannot accept the reality of flesh and blood, those lives not your own, those lives out of range that you rage to control.

Those women and the doctors and nurses and technicians who come to their aid are murderers, you say. A deep crazy anger wells up in you: you call it love. In the core of your movement you nurture a worm of hatred. Until it is ready to be born.

The ticking devices and the intricate metal weapons are your children. You gave them life. And now they speak in your name.