Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Tropes of tyranny





















The father of Malawi, Dr. Hastings Kamuzu Banda, whose longevity in years and in office might well depress opponents of Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe still further, is currently the subject of a posthumous personality cult, reports the Globe & Mail's Geoffrey York.


I don't like the notion of universal traits--I'm too much of a cultural relativist for that--but three comments in the article by ordinary Malawians gave me pause.
  • "He built hospitals, schools, universities - it's all because of him. The roads you travel, the development that you see in Malawi yesterday - it's all because of this man."
Why, regardless of place and culture, do people insist upon this bizarre synecdoche, which is even permitted to become almost literal in the case of Dear Leader Kim Jong-il and his god-like father--all other North Koreans being, in effect, little more than their bodily extensions? Bertold Brecht had a thing or two to say about that:

Who built Thebes of the seven gates?
In the books you will find the names of kings.
Did the kings haul up the lumps of rock?
And Babylon, many times demolished
Who raised it up so many times? In what houses
Of gold-glittering Lima did the builders live?
Where, the evening that the Wall of China was finished
Did the masons go? Great Rome
Is full of triumphal arches. Who erected them? Over whom
Did the Caesars triumph? Had Byzantium, much praised in song
Only palaces for its inhabitants? Even in fabled Atlantis
The night the ocean engulfed it
The drowning still bawled for their slaves.

The young Alexander conquered India.
Was he alone?
Caesar beat the Gauls.
Did he not have even a cook with him?
Philip of Spain wept when his armada.
Went down. Was he the only one to weep?
Frederick the Second won the Seven Years' War. Who
Else won it?

  • "Most of the atrocities in that time were actually done by people around him," [a caretaker at the Banda mausoleum] told a group of tourists. "When he was angry, he would say, 'I don't like this person, remove him.' People would misinterpret it and torture the person and jail him."
The classic Henry II defence: but lacking in cathedrals and knights, the Malawians had to make do with the more mundane police-stations and dungeons that are also, like the exalted notion of leadership, a near-universal feature of the modern nation-state.
  • "He himself was very good, even if his followers were bad."
"Ah, if the Tsar only knew." The trope of distancing, the fear of the gap between a leader and his people at once metaphorical and literal. Kafka raises that to the level of nightmare:

An Imperial Message

The Emperor—so they say—has sent a message, directly from his death bed, to you alone, his pathetic subject, a tiny shadow which has taken refuge at the furthest distance from the imperial sun. He ordered the herald to kneel down beside his death bed and whispered the message to him. He thought it was so important that he had the herald repeat it back to him. He confirmed the accuracy of the verbal message by nodding his head. And in front of the entire crowd of those who have come to witness his death—all the obstructing walls have been broken down and all the great ones of his empire are standing in a circle on the broad and high soaring flights of stairs—in front of all of them he dispatched his herald. The messenger started off at once, a powerful, tireless man. Sticking one arm out and then another, he makes his way through the crowd. If he runs into resistance, he points to his breast where there is a sign of the sun. So he moves forward easily, unlike anyone else. But the crowd is so huge; its dwelling places are infinite. If there were an open field, how he would fly along, and soon you would hear the marvellous pounding of his fist on your door. But instead of that, how futile are all his efforts. He is still forcing his way through the private rooms of the innermost palace. He will never win his way through. And if he did manage that, nothing would have been achieved. He would have to fight his way down the steps, and, if he managed to do that, nothing would be gained. He would have to stride through the courtyards, and after the courtyards the second palace encircling the first, and, then again, stairs and courtyards, and then, once again, a palace, and so on for thousands of years. And if he finally did burst through the outermost door—but that can never, never happen—the royal capital city, the centre of the world, is still there in front of him, piled high and full of sediment. No one pushes his way through here, certainly not with a message from a dead man. But you sit at your window and dream to yourself of that message when evening comes.


The "imagined community" of a nation has displaced the literal community: and, in its sheer magnitude it constantly threatens alienation from those who rule and speak in our name, and this is the case even under more democratic regimes.

Why, then, are the tropes of tyranny seemingly transcultural? Perhaps the answer, or at least a partial one, is this: as is the case with our current "universal" understanding of human rights, the modern nation is itself universal, and its construction, bearing a frankly Western institutional legacy, brings with it certain values and understandings that cross all borders. Simply look at the attire of the man above, who opened a replica of Eton College in his country in order to teach his impoverished people Greek and Latin.

But what, some might ask, do Western values of liberal democracy have to do with tyranny? Quite a bit when you think about it, and I'm not even referring to the sordid fact that our standard of living and the cheap imports that sustain us depend to a large extent upon tyranny at the source. Even tyrants (Stalin, Saddam Hussein) somehow required the validation of popular "elections"; their leadership, with its
stylized gestures, are different only in their local context and degree from (say) that of a Prime Minister who keeps a large portrait gallery of images of himself, or another one who says, "Just watch me."

In the modern tyrant we see as in a distorting mirror the everyday images of Western governance: elections that change nothing substantive, aloof leaders, social and economic hierarchies, a coercive state apparatus. To be sure, fear is generally replaced by that other political calming mechanism, apathy (unless you find yourself in a state of exception like Abousfian Abdelrazik or the various unfortunates Canada has rendered to other countries for torture, or holds on security certificates). But somehow Dr. Hastings Banda, in his three-piece suit and tie under the blazing African sun, seems rather too familiar, in ways that should trouble the genuine democrats among us.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

Discrimination and the market

Stephen Harper's mentor Tom Flanagan, taking time off from slagging the First Nations, has decided to target Canada's human rights commissions.

Shorter Flanagan:
"We don't need no legislation, we don't need no thought control."
I find myself wondering how a professor at a respectable university can get away with such a farrago of lies and half-truths, but no doubt tenure helps. Or maybe there's something in Calgary's drinking water.

Just check this out, for starters:

Both federal and provincial commissions are suffering blowback from their unsuccessful attempts to muzzle media gadflies Mark Steyn and Ezra Levant.

This has to be the single silliest sentence ever written about Canadian human rights commissions, and that bloviating narcissist Ezra Levant, as I need not remind readers, has set quite the benchmark in this respect. "Unsuccessful attempts to muzzle?" Muzzling might have been the aim of the complainants, but (I hope I'm not misremembering) didn't the various commissions and tribunals throw out the complaints? Every last cotton-picking one of them? And Mark Steyn, bless his cold-spirited Islamophobic heart, wasn't a respondent in any of them.

But Flanagan is merely warming to his task, which is to propose the Ausrottung of all human rights commissions, letting the market alone decide the discrimination question. "[I]ssues of prejudice and discrimination are far too complex," intones the Professor, "to be resolved by human-rights sloganeering."

Ah, yes, the market, that panacea for all human ills. It's expensive to discriminate, says the Professor. Non-discriminating employers get to choose from a larger labour pool; restaurants that discriminate make less money; racist landlords end up with empty apartments. So much for anti-Semitic "gentlemen's agreements" and restricted hotels, "No Irish Need Apply," "No Coloureds," and all of those other apparent figments of our historical imagination. Discrimination in the private sector, he says, is "self-liquidating," something that will come as news to the many successful complainants before any of our human rights tribunals, and I'm not talking about the "hate speech" provisions, either.

Yes, there was indeed discrimination in the past, the Professor concedes, and he offers us quite a selective list of examples, all instances of abuses by Big Gummint using "the coercive monopoly of the state." Hence (don't look down--we're taking quite a leap here) the government setting up institutions to counter discrimination in the private sector, he says, is a case of the fox guarding the henhouse. Only the public sector, he says, should be regulated in this way--assuming that anything is left of it if he and his prime ministerial protégé have their way.

Expensive to discriminate?
To give just one obvious counter-example, abolishing the commission-enforced "duty to accommodate," which levels the employment playing field for those with disabilities, would be out the window and down the street as soon as the ink on the repeal legislation was dry. It can cost money to accommodate, even if not so much as many believe. If employers didn't have to accommodate, most of them wouldn't. And, since Ezra Levant was mentioned, let me note that his own attitudes in this respect, and those of his wretched hangers-on, adumbrate the fate of the disabled under Flanagan's cure-all free enterprise regime.

Of course, it's actually cheap, not expensive, to discriminate. Whites-only landlords never had any difficulty finding tenants. Restaurateurs, movie-house proprietors and the construction trades thrived in the past despite explicitly racist practices. Whites-only nightclubs in Calgary are doing very nicely right now. Private enterprise didn't liquidate those practices--the government did, pushed by activists on the ground. And it clearly has more work to do.

But now there's pushback--indeed, there always has been, but in the midst of a deep recession it's becoming mainstream once again. No, you won't find people like Tom Flanagan openly defending crude discrimination per se, setting aside his assimilationist approach to Native Canadians. But, like the Speech Warriors™ going to bat for Nazis and homophobes, he's quite happy to enable it--all the while making the absurdly false claim that the unfettered market will eliminate it. Nope, Tom. Never has. Never will.

Monday, May 18, 2009

Lost weekend ramble





















Ever have one of those weekends that just slips away? No gardening done, grass needs cutting, and it appears to be the Year of the Dandelion. Tried tackling those little nasties, and my trowel promptly snapped in two. And then there's the summer thesis push, and the basement in which one can no longer move easily. (The word "clutter" doesn't even come close. Try "midden.") And my poor dog, suffering from an inflamed pancreas, simply will not touch his new diet, but he insists on his 6:00 am walk just the same.

All of which is to say, proceed with caution. I'm not in the best of moods. Blogging is an excuse for procrastination, the cause of much guilt, a diversion: but this weekend, frankly, not even that time-eating activity is bringing much joy.

There's a pile-on at one of my favourite blogs: my longtime commenter Marky Mark is getting pummeled for no discernible reason, and the egregious "shlemazl" claims, of course, that it's all motivated by anti-Semitism, as is everything else in heaven and on earth. He lied so atrociously, in fact, that Marky went over there to chide him.

Earlier this weekend, that same twerp helpfully provided an anonymous inquirer at his place with my real name and a (made-up) bio, but has since deep-sixed that. I won't say he thought better of it, because "shlemazl" doesn't think better of anything or anyone. More likely he's worried that I might do something similar to him--a very well-founded fear, as it happens.

Meanwhile, the bloom is off the Engage rose, as what I thought was a good-faith exchange of interpretations of Seven Jewish Children resulted in a display of incoherent, mocking defensiveness that I had thought, in my innocence, was largely absent over there. I'm having a far better discussion b/c with one of the Engage moderators, and we might both emerge from the shadows to debate the topic of anti-Semitism here and/or at his place, but I'm giving the Engage combox a wide berth for the moment. There are far more enjoyable ways of wasting one's time--if I could only find them.

And then, of course, there's the news: a dismal backdrop to be sure. As I had predicted well before his election, Obama is being digested by the machine, and his substance reassembled. Now he's all for the Guantanamo kangaroo courts, settling for tying a small weight to one hairy leg, and he quails at showing the photographic proof of American mistreatment of Iraqi prisoners. He doesn't want to investigate the previous administration's torture record, much less its apparent formulation of foreign policy by means of the sortes biblicae. He's pouring money and troops into the Afghan adventure, bailing out Big Business, and trying to be everybody's pal. No wonder all the conservatives have left is to challenge his choice of mustard.

Closer to home, though, the University of Saskatchewan has turned down a proposed racist endowment that reminded me immediately of the old Leonard Foundation scholarships. Good on the university for rejecting a "no Aboriginals need apply" fund. As the Globe & Mail points out, the claim by the flawed philanthropist that Aboriginal students are "basically taken care of" is a bit of a stretch. Only a small handful of the university's 4,148 scholarships--36 in all, total value $107,000--are reserved for Aboriginals.

But isn't even this "race-based," as surely as the proposed endowment? Before the cons sit down to dine on that, it's worth noting, as the editorialist does, that Aboriginals make up 18.9% of the 18-29-year-olds in Saskatchewan, but only 7.5% of the undergraduate population at the university. A small fund to encourage a grossly disadvantaged population to better itself is hardly the same as one that excludes it.

So, some good news among the bad, and now it's time to go buy a trowel if any place is open. We've had near-frost temperatures on top of everything else, so it's miserable outside, but I've declared war on the dandelion, and today, I hope, will be the day of reckoning.






















UPDATE: It cost one three-figure speeding ticket to discover that Canadian Tire had run out of the super weed extractor I rushed out to buy on the recommendation of commenter "Catelli." Once I have the dandelions out, by good old-fashioned trowelling, I'll probably bury myself in my own garden. :(

Sunday, May 17, 2009

" ... a lot of trust issues ..."

My co-blogger has been rigorously posting about the Braidwood inquiry, and closer to home, a recent incident involving an Ottawa police officer.

There is currently a police disciplinary hearing being held to review a number of complaints against Const. Daniel Bargh.

Bargh is charged with using the Canadian Police Information Centre inappropriately more than 100 times to find information on civilians, colleagues, girlfriends and his father. "I was getting better knowledge of activities and events that are happening in my area," Bargh, who is still on active duty, testified.

He claimed he ran names -- including his own, dozens of times -- to "view possible court outcomes, gain information about calls and refresh my memory for trials."

Last week, the hearing heard the databases -- which contain personal information like home addresses, previous complaints or criminal records -- are only for investigative purposes. The system tracks who uses it, by badge number, time and search name. Between Feb. 1, 2005, and Nov. 26, 2007, Bargh ran searches on 13 officers.

He also ran the name of the daughter of a police officer, a woman he had started a relationship with after he met her on a call in July 2007.

In April, Bargh faced a charge of using unnecessary force under the Police Services Act. A surveillance tape from the Shepherds of Good Hope seemed to show an officer beating up a drunk, homeless man at the shelter.
"Officers have the authority to use force in effecting an arrest, in dealing with their duties. But how much force, and what's necessary under the circumstances, that's what's of concern," said police service prosecutor Linda Bordeleau.
Though he was cleared of that charge, Bargh currently faces a number of allegations that his actions have been inappropriate, discreditable and in possible violation of his professional code of conduct.

He also stands charged with two counts of discreditable conduct, for allegedly associating with a man with a minor criminal record for drug possession, and for allegedly referring to a fellow officer using “derogatory and profane language while in the presence of a member of the public,” according to the internal charge. He pleaded not guilty to those charges, too.

Finally, he is charged with deceit for allegedly lying to a professional standards branch officer investigating his knowledge of the man with the criminal record. None of the offences are criminal, and Bargh remains on active duty.

As well, a colleague of Bargh testified at the disciplinary hearing that he believed Bargh provided personal information about him to a known drug dealer. This may well have been the last straw for fellow officers who were perhaps tolerating or covering for Bargh's actions.

As zoom blogged in her post at knitnut:

Every time a cop gets caught abusing his power and doing something illegal or disturbing, the force closes in protectively around its own. We’re encouraged to think of it as an isolated incident rather than a systemic problem. We hear that a thorough investigation will be carried out, and we should be patient because a thorough investigation takes months, but we’re assured that justice will prevail in the end. ...

‘Thorough’ investigations often end up going nowhere. If it comes down to one person’s word against another, the benefit of the doubt goes to the cop. Witnesses, understandably, aren’t comfortable coming forward against cops. Cops aren’t comfortable coming forward against other cops. So unless a case is absolutely rock-solid against a cop, and there are plenty of credible witnesses, bad cops seem to get away with atrocious and illegal behaviour. ...

The Chief's got his work cut out for him. I don’t think this is just about damage control, or optics, or the force’s image. I suspect it runs much deeper than that.


Dr Webster describes in his open letter to Zofia Cisowski (Robert Dziekanski's mother) the downfall of a police force culture that wields force with impunity. I hope, and trust that Chief Vern White will remove the bad apples from the Ottawa police force. As Dr Dawg said, something smells rotten.

Chuck Strahl: caught with his pants down
















Balbulican has the whole sorry tale. Just the latest example of Minister Strahl's staggering contempt for Native people.

Unaccountability at the IRB

It's not often that I can report agreement with the ubiquitous Jason Kenney and his puppy, neo-con Alykhan Velshi, but they do have a point in the Pobric case.

Briefly: in an act of supreme arrogance, Immigration Review Board adjudicator Lee Ann King has ruled that an immigration hearing in the case of a convicted killer from Bosnia will be closed to the public.


Elvir Pobric escaped from prison in 1996 and slipped into Canada in 1999, at which time he applied for refugee status. Apparently his conviction became known only later--there was an Interpol warrant, and a relative of one of his victims alerted the authorities here.

The police picked him up on April 28. The current hearing is to determine whether he will be released or held in custody pending a decision about deportation.


In a second, equally arrogant move, King declined to give any reasons for her decision to bar the public and the media.

One can only surmise the motives of Jason Kenney: one suspects that his interests do not extend to the notion of government accountability, given his personal intervention, contrary to the very fundamentals of administrative law, to deny a grant to a Canadian Muslim group for exercising its freedom of speech. But accountability is indeed the key issue here.

The IRB is and should remain an arms-length agency, free from political interference. That means that its officials have no direct accountability to the government or to Parliament. Yet that makes it pretty much a law unto itself, although its decisions are subject to judicial review. But should it not be accountable and transparent to the public whom it serves?

"Accountability" and "transparency" are buzzwords, of course, meaning what our current rulers want them to mean. There are many, many shades and nuances. And privacy, in the case of IRB hearings, is not an insignificant matter. Nonetheless, there is clearly a compelling public interest in this case that should far outweigh Pobric's privacy rights.

The man, not to put too fine a point on it, is a convicted cold-blooded killer, who stands at least a chance of being released and allowed to vanish into the general population. That the public is excluded from the hearing is bad enough: that a minor official should not even have to give reasons for her extraordinary decision is an outrage.

Kenney is right to call for a judicial review, whatever his reasons. It may not prevent the man from moving in next door to you under another name, but it's all we have, and the sooner it takes place the better. In the longer term, the terms of reference of the IRB obviously need to be reviewed: justice, as always, should be seen to be done.

Saturday, May 16, 2009

Engage!








I wish I'd known about this website earlier. Engage is a British pro-Israel, social democratic place that actually encourages debate. And for those of us who have had quite enough of the boorish shlemazl, for whom all "discussion" at his end begins and concludes with insults and accusations, it's a refreshing change.

Engage actually presents a stronger challenge to those of us on the left who are fairly hard-line on Israel than do right-wing bloggers and commentators who are satisfied
merely to call critics of Israel "anti-Semites" and leave it at that. I agree with very little that I've found over there, but there's real, chewy substance in the articles.

Editor David Hirsh has written a kind of position paper that is worth reading. I hardly know where to begin in critiquing it--for example, he posits "anti-Zionism" as a term to describe critiques of Israel, but by so doing he is setting up a straw man. I would not describe my position as "anti-Zionist." And I have no time whatsoever for his concept (to which I have referred in earlier posts) of the "Livingston Formulation," which suggests, incredibly, that complaints about being called an "anti-Semite" for criticizing Israel are themselves anti-Semitic.

But the paper was obviously not constructed by a fool. Would that the on-going debates about Israel and anti-Semitism could all be carried on at this level.

I'm not unequivocal about Engage, though. I have been taking part in a discussion here, and my second-ever post disappeared: after inquiring of one of the moderators, I was told that it had been suppressed because of a mention of Stalin at the end that had rubbed another moderator the wrong way. To the credit of the moderator in question, the comment was restored. But my fourth comment provoked a sharp b/c rebuke from him. Nevertheless...

...give it a whirl. In tone and substance, it towers above much of the unthinking, dishonest and emotive nonsense to which we have become accustomed.

UPDATE: And for some literate counterpoint, be sure to check out Jews sans Frontieres. [H/t commenter Gene]

Politics of mustard--the prequel



















Readers are well aware by now of the wingnut w**kfest over President Barack Obama's choice of condiment for his hamburger at Ray's Hell-Burger. Dijon mustard? "Hope you enjoyed your fancy burger, Mr. President," sneered Hal Turner's buddy Sean Hannity on (where else?) Faux News.

But a Hell-Burger isn't any old burger, and Ray's ain't exactly McDonald's. The beef patties there weigh in at 10 oz., and Ray offers them with foie gras, bordelaise sauce and white truffle oil if you prefer.

Never mind. There's no need to go over old ground, and it's uncharitable, in any case, to mock the insane.

What readers may not know, however, is that this was not the first brush with Dangerous Dijon that the President has encountered.

Twelve years ago, as he recounts in The Audacity of Hope, he managed to escape what might have been his undoing:


I first travelled through southern Illinois in 1997. It was the summer after my first term in the Illinois legislature, and Michelle and I were not yet parents. With session adjourned, no law school classes to teach, and Michelle busy with work of her own, I convinced my legislative aide, Dan Shomon, to toss a map and some golf clubs in the car and tool around the state for a week.

But as the date of our departure approached, it became apparent that he wasn't quite sure how I would be received in the counties we were planning to visit. Four times he reminded me how to pack – just khakis and polo shirts, he said; no fancy linen trousers or silk shirts. I assured him that I didn't own any linens or silks. On the drive down, we stopped at a TGI Friday's and I ordered a cheeseburger. When the waitress brought the food I asked her if she had any Dijon mustard. Dan shook his head.

"He doesn't want Dijon," he insisted, waving the waitress off. "Here" – he shoved a yellow bottle of French's mustard in my direction – "here's some mustard right here." The waitress looked confused. "We got Dijon if you want it," she said to me.

I smiled. "That would be great, thanks." As the waitress walked away, I leaned over to Dan and whispered that I didn't think there were any photographers around. [The Audacity of Hope. Vintage Books (first paperback edition, 2008), 60-61.
]

The unbearable lightness of American politics. If the media had caught wind of this appalling, traitorous, elitist, namby-pamby, foreign, special preference, would Obama's political career have been over before it began?


[H/t my wise neighbour Richard]

Sunset for the RCMP.

Yesterday Dr Dawg wrote about Mike Webster's revealing testimony at the Braidwood Inquiry.

This is the letter that Dr Webster wrote to Zofia Cisowski (Robert Dziekanski 's mother) published in the Globe and Mail.

While not 'le coup de grâce' to the RCMP that some might wish, Dr Webster's letter may well signal the tipping point, "the level at which the momentum for change becomes unstoppable", as defined by Malcolm Gladwell in his book, refining the expression as a sociological term: "the moment of critical mass, the threshold, the boiling point."

Today Gary Mason, a journalist at the Globe and Mail, adds his own perspective. The thirteen comments that follow his article express agreement with the points presented by Dr Webster.

The fourteenth comment is from Mason Wright, Globe and Mail evening news editor, apologizing for closing the comments section, citing 'legal reasons.'

The members of the toxic executive inner circle of the RCMP will not go quietly. They have demonstrated that they are willing to hold public safety in fealty to their imperatives, and the public hostage to their collective arrogance.

Friday, May 15, 2009

"Pro-life" savagery

Yesterday was the annual so-called "March for Life" in beautiful downtown Ottawa. Check out this video and the love for life expressed therein.



[H/t Soha Kneen via Twitter]

The Braidwood Chronicles: double smackdown












The Braidwood Inquiry is lurching to a conclusion, with testimony likely to finish next week and final arguments to be presented at the end of the month.

It's been a rough week for the Four Horsemen, and for Taser International, too.

First it was a police psychologist, Mike Webster, who has been training police forces for more than thirty years.
To say that he didn't mince words would be somewhat of an understatement.

"Fools rush in," he said. "They [the Four Horsemen] panicked and they abandoned their basic training and they embraced their more recent and questionable Taser training provided for them by their misguided employer."

Ouch.

And there was more:


Webster said that Dziekanski was clearly upset, after his "gruelling journey" of more than 30 hours from Poland to Vancouver without meeting his mother, and that he actually was glad to see the RCMP arrive to help him, calling out "Polizia, polizia," and dropping his hands to his side in a release of tension.

But then, Webster said, RCMP gave him conflicting commands to get his passport and when he turned to his suitcase to get it, told him to move away from his luggage and put his hands on the counter.

"Following the contrary commands came the pointing of at least one black leather-clad finger," said Webster, noting Dziekanski then threw up his hands in exasperation. Then came what Webster called the "circling of the wagons," as the officers surrounded him with their hands on their duty belts in a menacing fashion.

Said Webster: "Mr. Dziekanski was their client and it was their responsibility, not his, to take control and calm him down."


He still wasn't done. Describing the RCMP as a "sick" institution, he called senior management "dinosaurs" who are still in the "dark ages" of police work.

"
I am embarrassed," he said, "to be associated with organizations that Taser sick old men in hospital beds and confused immigrants arriving to the country. Frankly I find it embarrassing."

Unsurprisingly, the outspoken Webster has seen his consulting work with the RCMP dry up in the wake of his public comments. "Unfortunately the RCMP is not a healthy organization and is unable to take criticism," he said. "I've become something of a pariah."


Next it was the renowned forensic pathologist Dr. John Butt, awarded the Order of Canada in 2000 for his nearly four decades of work in the field.

Dr. Butt shredded the autopsy report of pathologist Dr. Charles Lee, who failed to mention the repeated Taserings that Robert Dziekanski had suffered, or the marks on his back caused by the Taser probes, but claimed that "chronic alcoholism" had contributed to his death. (Video here; testimony of Dr. Lee here.)

Butt disputed Lee's statement that heart damage had been present as a result of alcoholism:

"I think this is probably a cardiac-related death 'de novo,' a new event unheralded by previous symptoms," said Butt, noting that he reviewed Dziekanski's health records back to 1994 and found "no indication" of heart problems or high blood pressure.

As for the Taser:

"Given the circumstances of the death of Dziekanski, in my experience it would be uncommon for the role of a weapon (e.g. Taser) to be left without a discussion as was so in Lee's report," noted Butt's report.

Butt also urged that "caution is advisable about use of the term 'excited delirium,'" which has often been cited as a cause of death following Taser use. Butt said that "diagnosis" is "questioned by those practising psychiatry . . . (and) often is defined by persons who have neither training in nor experience with aberrant behaviour."

Concluded Butt: "I believe that increasing exertion and stress seen following the discharge of the Taser likely contributed to the death of Robert Dziekanski."

It's hard to imagine how the RCMP as an institution could absorb much more punishment than it has received over the past several weeks of the inquiry and remain standing. It seems, in fact, that the force is shifting its position in advance of Justice Braidwood's conclusions, judging from the belated apology
by Deputy Commissioner William Sweeney a few days ago delivered to a Senate Committee studying RCMP reforms. This follows another official apology two weeks ago from senior media relations officer Sgt. Tim Shields.

"We are very sorry for Mr. Dziekanski's death," said Sweeney. "We are committed to learning as much as possible from the circumstances surrounding his tragic death."

"We must spend more time with our training to use de-escalation techniques in a much more effective manner than perhaps we have in the past," he said. "In my day, it was always talking. We prided ourselves on time, talk and, if necessary, tear gas before we attempted to do any sorts of interventions that would physically cause harm to others."

This sounds as though the RCMP is all but throwing in the towel, even if Sweeney hedged, cautioning that
"[s]ometimes things happen so quickly that the outcome is not one we would have desired." But that's pretty flabby stuff, given what we have learned so far about the conduct of the Four Horsemen before, during and after the killing of Robert Dziekanski.

Judging from his words as a whole, we might safely conclude that their futures in the RCMP are not bright. But they are, as Webster and many others have indicated, a mere symptom of serious institutional disease. And that is likely incurable, no matter what the outcome of the inquiry.

Hoist. Petard.




















"If you don't like being told to "go back to where you came from", then don't conduct your protests under a foreign flag." --Kate McMillan


[H/t Robert McClelland]

Thursday, May 14, 2009

Of banning, hypocrisy and empathy

I opened up a discussion earlier this week about my decision to ban long-time commenter and blogger Jay Currie. Comments came from across the political field. I'm still digesting them, and getting a bit of a chuckle, I must admit, from some of the commentary on a parallel thread at his place. What a charming collection of liars and pretentious half-wits he has on his side. But I digress.

Words like "echo-chamber" are being tossed around over there, and this ripe bit of buffoonery from Currie himself: "
It is an interesting example of how the pomo lefty mind works. Lacking arguments, the first move is libel and the second is to crush dissent."

Crushing dissent, eh? That's a bit rich, coming from the starboard side of the 'sphere. I have been banned by Kate McMillan (for the crime of quoting some of her commenters), warned off by Mick Hartley (for defending Terry Eagleton too vigorously), and given a prompt heave-ho by Terry Glavin (who brooks no dissent of any kind at his place, as others will attest). I was pitched from Dust My Broom because the owner disapproved of someone on my blogroll, I lasted about half a day at Speech Warrior™ Nick Packwood's place (Ghost of a Flea), and my comments at Ezra Levant's dive have tended to vanish down the memory hole. And that evil little imp Kathy Shaidle, of course, doesn't allow comments from anyone.

Not a peep out of Currie and his gibbering cheerleaders about any of this, of course. Good grief, the hypocrisy is so thick in that quarter that you could bang your head on it.

But back to the reason for my ban. Obviously it wasn't to "crush dissent," or a lot of the comments on my previous post would never have seen the light of day. It was, as I said at the time, a question of value, not opinion.

A generalization: the Right simply lacks empathy. It's a kind of political Asperger Syndrome. You can easily multiply the examples: when people were drowning like rats in New Orleans, the immediate response of the Right (and Currie was up there with the rest of them) was to blame and mock the victims. Eliminationist rhetoric--wishing political opponents dead--is commonplace on that side of the aisle.

The crushing of a peace activist under an Israeli bulldozer serves merely as an occasion for obscene laughter. The slaughter of Tamils is openly advocated. Reacting to this, I am accused of possessing an "overdone sympathy for people of colour," a fastidious version of that venerable term,
"n----r-lover." (One certainly can't accuse these conservatives of sympathy, overdone or otherwise, when victims of natural or man-made disasters are off-white or politically to the left.)

Of course there are empathetic conservatives, usually of the old school--some regular commenters here, for instance--but the new conservatives generally seem to regard empathy as a vice.

I find that abhorrent--and, admittedly, frightening. "There is no such thing as society," said Maggie Thatcher, as she pulled the wings off a fly. And if everyone were missing that vital part of the human psyche, there would indeed be no society, just a dwindling number of brutes clubbing and being clubbed. A Randian dream.

I've been mulling over my decision, nonetheless. A lot of thoughtful people have commented, pro and con. Some of the "unban" folks are political allies, people I have long respected. Maybe I should invite Currie back to "
live to be the show and gaze o' the time," because he does manifest, at a more literate level than that of his grunting fellows, the fundamental flaws in both politics and character that are the hallmarks of today's conservatives. These need all the critique we can provide. Besides, if folks want to have at him, they shouldn't have to enter his squalid den and endure the inevitable spitting and hissing from the corners.

Unbanned, then. My house has many mansions. Just try not to make a mess on the carpet, and leave the mammals alone.

















.

Is the fix in? [updated]













An off-duty Ottawa police officer implicated in a vicious assault on a taxi driver yesterday is still on active duty. He has been identified as a marine officer in the Ottawa Police Service's East Division.

None of the local news outlets, including the Ottawa Citizen, has carried this identifying information: it appeared in the North Bay Nugget. Here's more:

Const. Alain Boucher, a police spokesman, said the force wasn't looking for any help from the public on the investigation.

--

Steve Boucher, president of the police association, called the officer a "very decent individual" who received minor injuries in the confrontation.

The officer was "swarmed" by cabbies, said Boucher, who believes the officer will be cleared of wrongdoing after the investigation.

A thought-experiment: suppose a taxi-driver had viciously beaten an off-duty Ottawa police officer. Would he be driving his cab today? Would the police be warning away the public, saying, in effect, "We don't need your help, thanks?" Would the cabbie have been allowed to drive away from the scene of the attack? Would no charges have been laid? Would the cabbie's name be kept out of the media? (If anyone can identify the officer, I shall publish his name here. The public has a right to know just who is "serving and protecting" them.)

The results of the internal police "investigation," carried out by the officer's colleagues, "won't be known for some time."

"I pray to God he's not a policeman," said the victim, Sami Aldoboni, who was not then in the know. "A bad apple like that would hurt the good people of policing."

This poor man, I suspect, is about to learn an important civics lesson.

UPDATE: (May 14) Well, well. The Ontario Special Investigations Unit has stepped in, putting the Ottawa police internal investigation on hold. The SIU will be investigating the conduct of the off-duty cop to determine if criminal charges should be laid. The assailant has been placed on desk duty until the investigation is completed. While it's still police investigating police, and a whitewash is possible, this is clearly a positive development.

Yesterday afternoon, representatives of the taxi drivers' union (CAW) met with Ottawa Police Chief Vern White, a man who has made serious attempts to reach out to the community ever since he replaced the cocky, old-school Vince Bevan. The meeting apparently went well. The behaviour of the off-duty cop and his buddies on the force who arrived at the scene will be reviewed internally once the SIU investigation has concluded. White's spokesperson, Inspector Mike Flanagan, has promised transparency.

And that's just what the public is demanding. According to city councillor Eli El-Chantiry, his phone and those of his fellow councillors have been ringing off the hook with calls from irate citizens. In an editorial, the Ottawa Citizen makes the key point: "Ottawans will not stand for abuse of power in their police service. Chief White faces a major test of his credibility."


UPDATE: The assailant has been identified as Const. Shyldon Safruk, a member of the police marine unit. His foster brother says he's an "easygoing" kind of guy. His Facebook page has been disabled.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

In the land of the nipper-tipper [final update]

In a southern Ontario backwater called Keswick, racism more associated with that other South flourishes--with the tacit approval of at least some small-town officials.

This is the area in which local residents have been wont to throw any Asian-origin people they encounter into Lake Simcoe for the crime of angling.The practice has a name--"nipper-tipping"--the word "nipper," like that other n-word, being a racial slur.

It's trouble-makers--that's the official version. Not even necessarily racist. Just some local lads out on a tear.

But Keswick has had other problems, too. Residents woke up two years ago to find homophobic and anti-Semitic graffiti spray-painted on houses and cars. A swastika was scrawled on the Sutton District High School: school board spokesperson Ross Virgo said at the time, "It's seen as an isolated, singular act of mischief."

Now Keswick in the news again. A bright 15-year-old Asian-Canadian boy was confronted by a racist bully on the school grounds, who proceeded to call him a "fucking Chinese" and punch him in the mouth. His victim, who had had some martial arts training, struck one blow with his left hand and put the bully out of the fight with a broken nose. Quite literally, it seems, this kid can take his opponent with one hand tied behind his back, as the old challenge has it.

This is the point, however, at which the official connection to racism in the area became apparent. The police were called: they arrested the bullying victim and have criminally charged him with assault. The school initially suspended him for twenty days, and the principal, one Catherine McGinley, has recommended to the York Region District School Board that he be expelled, not only from Keswick High School, but from all schools in the region. Meanwhile the bully has had not even a word of reproof from the authorities.*

This classic get-out-of-town message, however, has met with resistance, it being 2009 and all. Three hundred students walked out of McGinley's school to protest, and the aforementioned Ross Virgo now claims that McGinley's letter was a mistake, that after further investigation no expulsion was being contemplated--although no one thought to inform the family, who had been thoughtfully copied on it.

Meanwhile the police have re-opened the case and are investigating the attack on the 15-year-old as a possible hate crime. And the local mayor has visited the family to assure them that they are welcome in his town.

Amazing what a little national publicity can do. The frantic backpedalling of various officials, all of whom had leaped to punish an Asian-Canadian kid without bothering to investigate the circumstances, is a heartwarming sight to see. But the story isn't over by a long shot. The boy has begun serving his 20-day suspension, and he still faces criminal charges. The bully continues to go to class, and at this point faces no charges at all.

This cannot stand. Why not be heard? Send politely-worded comments to the school principal here; to the local she'iff York Regional Chief of Police Armand P. La Barge here; and to the Crown Attorney's office by fax at (905)853-4849.

UPDATE: Blogger leftdog brings us Keswick High's anti-bullying policy:


Bullying can take the form of physical, verbal, or emotional abuse directly or over communication networks (cyber bullying). At Keswick High School, there is a zero-tolerance policy on bullying which is supported by the York Region District School Board, and the Ministry of Education of Ontario.


UPPERDATE: (May 5) Nothing like a little sunshine to put things right. The school board has reversed itself, and the kid is back in class with no mark on his academic record. Now we wait for the Crown Attorney to withdraw the one-sided charges laid by the York Regional Police.

Spokesperson Ross Virgo stated that in the future the board would ensure that “school leaders have the benefit of all the information that's available to them from the outset.” Noting the obvious, he continued: “The school recognizes that this whole situation could have benefited from a more thorough investigation from the outset and it deeply regrets the premature sending of that expulsion letter.”


[H/t The Galloping Beaver.]

UPPESTDATE: (May 7) And now the Chief of York Regional Police has admitted that the initial police investigation had been "flawed from the outset," and called yesterday for the Crown to drop the charges. Chief La Barge praised the students who walked out of Keswick High for initiated his review: "Without hesitation, it was the student protest," he said.

[H/t reader "sassy"]

FINALE: (May 13) And at last--closure.

___________________
*Correction: Reports confirm that the bully, too, was suspended, for the same length of time as his intended victim.

Standards















Readers will know that, at least recently, I have tried to keep my eye on the news rather than on other bloggers, although admittedly some of the low-hanging fruit on the Right is difficult to resist. I run an open comments section, and generally we all manage to keep the debates civil.

The commenters who venture over here, from across the political spectrum, tend to cooperate in this: and
the result is some intense conversation that very often gets beneath the surface of events, and well past the political clichés, into a genuine exploration of the issues.

I don't tend to rule with a heavy hand over here, although regulars are aware that I don't have any time for trollin' and cussin'. As I've said before, this is a family blog, G-rated, and I'd like to keep it that way.

So far, so good. But there are times when I do intervene. I won't tolerate racism here, for example. I won't tolerate comments that make light of genocide. There are limits. This is not a First Amendment blog.

In the comments on my "URQ QOTY" post, which was simply a quotation from Canada's first-ranked conservative blogger, who urged the genocide of the Tamils in Sri Lanka so that traffic could get back to normal in Toronto, commenter "Raphael Alexander" (not his real name) asked a question:


But do you have an opinion on the illegal closure of a major highway artery in the largest city in Canada?

And commenter Jay Currie responded thus:

Raphael, nothing but a legitimate show of support for an illegal terrorist organization holding civilians hostage in a warzone. Pretty much taught Hamas and Hezbollah everything they know. So, of course, it's Kate who's the problem here.

Now, understand the context. In Sri Lanka, genocide is happening before our eyes. Between 50,000-100,000 Tamils are bottled up in a three-kilometre-square piece of land, under continual bombardment from Sinhalese forces. The last hospital in the zone has been shelled for two days straight. The United Nations has called that as a war crime, and described the on-going extermination of Tamils by government forces as a "bloodbath."

The Sri Lankan government, which forbids journalists from approaching the kill zone, claims that the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) are shelling their own people. No one with a milligram of cortical matter, of course, believes that for one moment.

There is a large Tamil community in Canada, whose friends and families are being ethnically cleansed as I write. In a desperate cry for help, they have crowded onto highways to block traffic, first in Ottawa, and more recently in Toronto. "Do something!" they are saying. "Make it stop!" Perhaps there is nothing we can do officially but wring our hands; but these people have strayed well beyond our usual Canadian calm. Their families are being slaughtered. And that has made them demonstrative.

But unimpeded traffic-flow for some is more important than human lives, particularly the lives of brown people. Kate just wants the Sri Lankan forces to finish the job; and "Raphael" (and to be fair, many others) want the traffic to get moving again.

Enter Jay Currie, who ventured the comment reproduced above. He jumps to the defence of a person who has just advocated genocide. He deliberately misrepresents the protests (they are not a "show of support" for the LTTE, but an anguished plea for official assistance). He reproduces Sri Lankan propaganda, claiming that the tens of thousands of Tamil civilians being remorselessly slaughtered by the Sri Lankan armed forces are LTTE hostages. And he shows not a whit of concern about that slaughter.

I had this to say in reply:

Congratulations, Jay, for the revisionist post of the year.

The Sinhalese have the Tamils bottled up in a tiny bit of land and are shelling them mercilessly, Tigers and civilians alike. Thousands are dying. And the best you can do is tell us that the Tigers are on a terrorist list in Canada? The friends and families desperately acting out their angst in Canada at the impending slaughter of their loved ones are--what?--worthy of a stupid, snarky comment?

You've provided the weakest excuse for genocide I've ever heard--worse even than supporting it because some traffic was slowed down, as the wretched Kate did. Frankly, I'm beginning to understand, as I've never fully understood before, the meaning of the phrase "the banality of evil."

I gave you a pass (eventually) on the "pancake" nonsense, because I thought it might have been a kind of over-the-top boyish exuberance that you were too stubborn to withdraw. But I'm afraid this reveals that you're simply a nasty, racist piece of goods. Begone.


And I banned him.

Readers are free to comment on this, should they so choose. Perhaps I went too far. Perhaps I misread Jay's comment. In the cold light of day, I don't believe that I did: the implications in his comment still seem rather stark. In any case, he has responded, to the applause of his regular gang of lightweights, and in fairness I am linking to his piece.

The thrust of his post, if "thrust" is the right word--his heart doesn't really seem to be in it--is that I am banning opinion that conflicts with mine. Those regulars who continually nip at my heels here might be amused to hear that. It's not political opinion at issue in this case; it's common decency. Those who find cause for amusement in peace protesters being run over by bulldozers, or who make light of genocide, are simply not welcome here.

If I overreacted, I'm sure some of my commenters will tell me. But, as pompous as it sounds, I do have standards, and I feel a strong need to maintain them in my own house.

UPDATE: I should have drawn attention to this telling phrase in Currie's response: "
[Dawg's] overdone sympathy for people of colour". Shorter Jay: I'm a "n----r-lover."

Ottawa Police: something smells

Admittedly this is only one side of the story, but perhaps it will make readers as uncomfortable as it did me.

An Ottawa taxi driver, Sami Aldobani, is nursing a broken wrist, broken fingers and other injuries after being attacked by a thug in an apparent fit of road rage.

The thug followed him down the Airport Parkway into the Airport Taxi parking lot. Both men exited their cars, and the thug shouted racist insults, then proceeded to beat the taxi driver savagely until fellow cabbies pulled him off and restrained him.

This is where it gets interesting. The thug hauled out a police ID and showed it to a witness, one of thirty or so who had gathered. Two police officers arrived a few minutes later, he showed them his ID, and the two officers then told the gathering crowd to back off.

The police officers then got into the back seat of the thug's grey Nissan Xterra SUV and the thug drove away with them. Four other officers arrived, and one drove the officers' patrol car away.

The cabbie spent the night in hospital. The cops say that they are holding no one in custody at present, but are "investigating."

More of the culture of cop impunity? You decide.

UPDATE: Local CBC news is reporting that the assailant was indeed a police officer. He remains on active duty while the alleged "investigation" continues. A police spokesperson said the latter "may take some time." Anyone seen this movie before?

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Control freaks

















There is nothing wrong with your television set. Do not attempt to adjust the picture. We are controlling transmission. If we wish to make it louder, we will bring up the volume. If we wish to make it softer, we will tune it to a whisper. We will control the horizontal. We will control the vertical. We can roll the image, make it flutter. We can change the focus to a soft blur or sharpen it to crystal clarity. For the next hour, sit quietly and we will control all that you see and hear. --The Outer Limits

First it was Bernie Farber of the Canadian Jewish Congress, helping to prevent impressionable young children in Toronto from being exposed to a book called Three Wishes: Palestinian and Israeli Children Speak. A discussion of the issue may be found here.

Later that same year (2006), a play about a pro-Palestinian activist, My Name Is Rachel Corrie, was shut down because it "might offend the Jewish community."

More recently, the battle trumpets have been sounded by Farber and by the indefatigable Shimon Fogel of the Canada-Israel Committee, because Al-Jazeera English has applied for a broadcasting licence in Canada.

Here's a taste of Farber's bafflegab:

Asked why Al-Jazeera English should not be given a Canadian licence when it is carried by an Israeli provider, Farber replied, “Israel must deal with issues pertinent to its geopolitical circumstances. Canada is in a much different situation with laws that address broadcasting, all of which must be adhered to.”

But Fogel is far more blunt:

Israelis have multiple sources of news and analysis that all focus on the same issues and the same level of intensity as Al-Jazeera, minus the distortion. Here in Canada, however, the audience is considerably more naive and lacks the capacity to view the broadcast in a critical way, or to seek alternative perspectives.

And let's not forget Frank Dimant of B'nai Brith and his bizarre misreading of Caryl Churchill's play, Seven Jewish Children:

The City of Toronto should not allow a venue that it funds to be the staging ground for a divisive play that promotes anti-Jewish hatred. As its name denotes, 'Seven Jewish Children' does not even pretend to target Israel exclusively. It is clearly aimed at maligning Jews, depicting them as oppressors of Palestinians, blood-thirsty aggressors and child killers. It disturbingly inverts history, using Holocaust imagery to allege that the Jews, once the victims, are actively teaching their own children callous disregard for the suffering of others.

Dimant was in the news earlier this year, commending Carleton University for banning a poster he didn't like, and demanding that "Israeli Apartheid Week," a series of events taking place on numerous university campuses, be shut down.

How nice for us to have this gaggle of professional lobbyists around to protect naive, uncritical Canadians like me from seeing and hearing the wrong things and hence drawing "tainted and compromised" conclusions. How wonderful to have this protection virtually from the cradle to the grave.

Man, I'm going to get into trouble for this. The Usual Suspects will pounce, braying about the latest instance, right here at Dawg's Blawg, of International Jewish Conspiracy talk. The Protocols of the Learned Elders of Zion will get a mention. And "left anti-Semitism," of course. But the truth is far more mundane.

In Canada there are all sorts of ethnic lobby groups. (It's OK to call them ethnic lobby groups, by the way--with one exception.) They all advocate for their constituencies, are politically active, work with the media, and so on. They're involved as citizens, and their existence enriches the social and political culture of this country.

But it's also OK to be critical of these groups when their advocacy crosses the line and becomes anti-democratic. And what we are seeing in the instant case is precisely that: advocates who want to shut down debate, censor and ban. There's no conspiracy here, nothing secretive, and plenty of Jewish opposition, like Jewish Independent Voices (scroll to the end). In reality it's just a handful of control-freaks on a power trip, and these come in all shapes, sizes, ethnicities and colours. As citizens, however, it is our right and indeed our duty to push back.

Sometimes I wonder: whatever happened to the Jewish love of disputation? My old friends used to get into lengthy, arm-waving late-night discussions with me at the drop of a hat. Amos Oz, in This Land of Israel, describes an incident in that country where he was pulled into a discussion by right-wingers, told to sit down with them, peppered with questions, given cigarettes, listened to, harangued.... There was no talk of banning; there was heated debate, but no hatred. Nobody told him to shut up--indeed, they wanted him to speak, to argue with them. Engagement was the thing.

Farber, Dimant and Fogel could learn a lesson or two from them.

Monday, May 11, 2009

Larrygate [updated]









We can dream. But this case raises so many questions.

Here's the timeline. Terry Kilrea, no slouch himself in the thick-as-a-post right-winger department, withdrew his candidacy during the 2006 mayoralty election campaign, and threw his miniscule support behind the incumbent mayor Bob Chiarelli rather than the more conservative Larry O'Brien.

Why did Kilrea take himself out of contention? Why didn't he support his natural ally in looks, brains and politics? Why, shortly after the election, did he come out swinging with the affidavit that landed Larry in such a heap of trouble? And what's the food like at Hy's Steakhouse?

The trial resumes this week.
Here's the Ottawa Citizen Larry O'Brien trial site, the CBC Larry O'Brien trial site and the Ottawa Sun Larry O'Brien trial site.

Win, draw or lose, I hope the process wipes that revolting smirk off his face.

[h/t ZeroMeansZero]

UPDATE
: (May 11) Today's hearing, and the proceedings in the days to come, via Twitter.

URQ QOTY

"Hey Sri Lanka, would you just hurry up and finish them off so traffic can get back to normal?"

--Kate McMillan, Small Dead Animals